| Platinum | YOU'LL NEVER GET THIS | Earn all Trophies in Holy Potatoes! A Weapon Shop?! | 10.1% Rare | 100 pts |
| Silver | For Peace And Love | Forge 50 Katanas | 10.6% Rare | 36 pts |
| Silver | World Series Whacker | Forge 50 Throwing Weapons | 10.6% Rare | 36 pts |
| Silver | Because We Love Our Land | Forge 50 Rifles | 10.6% Rare | 36 pts |
| Silver | Fire Fight | Forge 50 Cannons | 10.6% Rare | 36 pts |
| Silver | Spearrific! | Forge 50 Spears | 10.8% Rare | 36 pts |
| Bronze | One Shot, One Kill | Forge 50 Pistols | 10.9% Rare | 24 pts |
| Bronze | Cannons, Away! | Forge 25 Cannons | 11.1% Rare | 24 pts |
| Bronze | Superb Staffcarver | Forge 50 Staffs | 11.2% Rare | 23 pts |
| Bronze | Not For Killin' | Forge 25 Katanas | 11.4% Rare | 23 pts |
| Bronze | Home Run Hitter | Forge 25 Throwing Weapons | 11.5% Rare | 23 pts |
| Bronze | Hack And Slash | Forge 50 Swords | 11.7% Rare | 23 pts |
| Gold | She's My What?! | Complete Luke Spudwalker's Request | 12.4% Rare | 44 pts |
| Bronze | Olympian! | Forge 25 Spears | 12.5% Rare | 22 pts |
| Bronze | My Rifles, My Buddy, And Me | Forge 25 Rifles | 12.6% Rare | 22 pts |
| Bronze | Gunslinger | Forge 25 Pistols | 12.8% Rare | 22 pts |
| Gold | Formed S.P.U.D. | Hire Tony Starch in your shop | 13.2% Rare | 43 pts |
| Bronze | Wanderful | Forge 50 Wands | 13.5% Rare | 21 pts |
| Gold | Love Wins | Complete Wolverinnie's Request | 13.8% Rare | 41 pts |
| Silver | Yummy Rum In My Tum | Complete Johnny Sparrow's Request | 14.5% Rare | 30 pts |
| Silver | Hired A God! | Hire Haepharion in your shop | 14.8% Rare | 30 pts |
| Silver | The Spud Who Lived | Complete Hairy Pota(to)'s Request | 15.7% Rare | 29 pts |
| Bronze | A Wizard's Best Assistant | Forge 25 Staffs | 15.7% Rare | 19 pts |
| Silver | Pigeons Are Love, Pigeons Are Life | Hire Nikola Taterla in your shop | 15.8% Rare | 29 pts |
| Bronze | Sitting Pretty On Forty-Three | Forge 50 Axes | 15.8% Rare | 19 pts |
| Bronze | I Put On My Sword And Special Belt | Complete Kamen Tater's Request | 16.2% Rare | 19 pts |
| Bronze | Defeat Is Not An Option! | Complete Spudttousai's Request | 16.2% Rare | 19 pts |
| Bronze | S.U.C.C.E.S.S. | Complete David's Request | 16.7% Rare | 18 pts |
| Bronze | I'm On Seventeen! | Forge 50 Bows | 17% Rare | 18 pts |
| Bronze | I Just Want A Good Game | Complete Blue Boy's Request | 17.2% Rare | 18 pts |
| Bronze | Open Sesame! | Complete The Locksmith's Request | 17.2% Rare | 18 pts |
| Bronze | Crush Your Enemies! | Forge 25 Swords | 17.3% Rare | 18 pts |
| Bronze | They See Me Stabbin', They Hatin' | Forge 50 Daggers | 17.4% Rare | 18 pts |
| Bronze | Chemicals Now Bubbling | Hire Heisenberger in your shop | 18.8% Rare | 17 pts |
| Bronze | Half-Life 3 Confirmed | Complete Gordon TrappedMan's Request | 19.1% Rare | 17 pts |
| Bronze | The Heart Reforged | Complete Hero's Request | 21.3% Uncommon | 16 pts |
| Silver | Dora | Get 2,500 items from explorations | 21.5% Uncommon | 24 pts |
| Bronze | I Have No Meowmory Of This Place | Complete Nyandalf the Grey's Request | 22.4% Uncommon | 15 pts |
| Bronze | Pew Pew Pew | Forge 25 Wands | 24% Uncommon | 15 pts |
| Bronze | Do You Even Lift, Bro? | Complete Kratatoes' Request | 25.8% Uncommon | 14 pts |
| Bronze | The Galaxy Fulfilled | Hire Okazaki Masamune in your shop | 26.4% Uncommon | 14 pts |
| Bronze | For Science | Complete POTaDOS' Request | 29.6% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | And My Axe! | Forge 25 Axes | 30.6% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | You Have My Bow | Forge 25 Bows | 35.3% Uncommon | 12 pts |
| Bronze | Et Tu, Brute? | Forge 25 Daggers | 38.4% Uncommon | 11 pts |
| Bronze | Fallen Petals | Complete Claude Strife's Request | 41.4% Common | 11 pts |