| Platinum | Platinum Chalice | You unlocked all other trophies. | 8.5% Very Rare | 111 pts |
| Silver | Boy of mystery | Keep quiet about your past. | 9.6% Very Rare | 39 pts |
| Gold | Care, like a brother cares | Use every opportunity to teach Martha how to use your slingshot. | 11.4% Rare | 46 pts |
| Silver | Staring contest champion | Return the stare. | 12.2% Rare | 33 pts |
| Bronze | Lone wolf | Become enemies with Alfred. | 12.6% Rare | 22 pts |
| Silver | Rebel without a cause | Get into trouble with the Earl of Shiring. | 14.2% Rare | 31 pts |
| Silver | Everything's in order | Bring order into William's chaos. | 15.3% Rare | 29 pts |
| Gold | Silentium est aureum | Let the others do the talking. | 15.6% Rare | 38 pts |
| Silver | Twist of fate | Wisen up before you cause great disaster. | 16.3% Rare | 28 pts |
| Gold | Friar Tuck | Steal from the Bishop at every opportunity. | 20.5% Uncommon | 33 pts |
| Gold | Good midwife | Be especially supportive during birth. | 22.8% Uncommon | 31 pts |
| Gold | Negotiation skills | Negotiate the best deal for Kingsbridge. | 23.9% Uncommon | 30 pts |
| Silver | Wannabe knight | Try to become a knight. | 27.8% Uncommon | 20 pts |
| Silver | Help an old friend | Take care of your pony. | 30.3% Uncommon | 19 pts |
| Gold | Full house | Invite everybody to the chapter meeting. | 30.4% Uncommon | 26 pts |
| Gold | End of Book One | Complete Book One. | 31.9% Uncommon | 25 pts |
| Bronze | Garden of Eden | Support Milius' dream of a garden. | 33.9% Uncommon | 12 pts |
| Bronze | Friends of sorts | Become friends with Alfred. | 34.2% Uncommon | 12 pts |
| Silver | Yet another secret | Unlock a secret room in Kingsbridge. | 37.2% Uncommon | 17 pts |
| Silver | Man of politics | Get involved in your brother's politics. | 38.4% Uncommon | 17 pts |
| Bronze | Tattletale | Report a crime to the monks in Kingsbridge. | 43.9% Common | 10 pts |
| Bronze | Let there be darkness | Dim the lights in the cathedral. | 45.3% Common | 10 pts |