| Platinum | Poseidon | All Trophies received | 2% Ultra Rare | 264 pts |
| Silver | Lean Back | Patrols fought 500 battles | 2% Ultra Rare | 99 pts |
| Silver | David-Versus-Goliath | Win a battle against at least 60 guns with a pinnace | 2.2% Ultra Rare | 93 pts |
| Silver | Whizz-Kid | Maximize all abilities of a captain
| 2.3% Ultra Rare | 91 pts |
| Silver | Collector's Instinct | Possess all ship types in one game
| 2.4% Ultra Rare | 89 pts |
| Gold | … Vici! | Take control over 30 towns in a single game | 2.5% Ultra Rare | 115 pts |
| Silver | D-Fence | Defend a town from 5 attacks | 2.6% Ultra Rare | 85 pts |
| Bronze | Davy Jones' Locker | 1,000 vessels sunk | 3% Ultra Rare | 52 pts |
| Silver | Lord Of War | Possess 5,000 cannons in a single game | 3.1% Ultra Rare | 76 pts |
| Bronze | Hunt For Booty | Loot 25,000 barrels | 3.1% Ultra Rare | 51 pts |
| Gold | … Vidi … | Take control over 15 towns in a single game | 3.2% Ultra Rare | 100 pts |
| Bronze | Hoarding | Possess 250,000 barrels of goods in a single game | 3.3% Ultra Rare | 49 pts |
| Silver | Disposable Weapons | Use up 4,000 handheld weapons in boarding combats | 3.4% Ultra Rare | 72 pts |
| Bronze | Crow's Nest | Discover 10 pirate nests in a single game | 3.7% Ultra Rare | 46 pts |
| Bronze | Power Drinker | Visit all 60 taverns | 3.9% Ultra Rare | 44 pts |
| Silver | Checkmate | Reduce a nation's number of towns down to two
| 4% Ultra Rare | 65 pts |
| Silver | Sea Dog | Spend 50 hours in the Caribbean | 4.7% Ultra Rare | 59 pts |
| Silver | Puppet Master | Occupy 15,000 employees in a single game | 5% Very Rare | 57 pts |
| Bronze | Beelzebub | Highest fame as 'Pirate' | 5.4% Very Rare | 36 pts |
| Silver | Aye aye, Capt‘n! | Reach the highest rank | 5.6% Very Rare | 53 pts |
| Silver | Veni … | Take control over 5 towns in a single game | 5.6% Very Rare | 53 pts |
| Bronze | Hypocritical | Pray 10 times | 6.6% Very Rare | 32 pts |
| Bronze | Arm Of The Law | Destroy 10 pirate hideouts | 6.9% Very Rare | 31 pts |
| Bronze | Keelhaul | Rescue 100 sailors from sharks | 7.1% Very Rare | 31 pts |
| Bronze | Wolf In Sheep's Clothing | Highest fame as 'Privateer' | 7.7% Very Rare | 29 pts |
| Bronze | Wedding Bells | Marry | 8.5% Very Rare | 28 pts |
| Bronze | Peacemaker | Take over a town by peaceful methods | 8.5% Very Rare | 28 pts |
| Bronze | Flawless Victory | Win a battle without taking any damage | 8.9% Very Rare | 27 pts |
| Silver | Treasure Chest | Save 4 million gold pieces in a single game | 9.1% Very Rare | 40 pts |
| Bronze | Landlubber | Build 250 buildings | 9.6% Very Rare | 26 pts |
| Bronze | Conqueror | A town annexation by martial methods | 10% Rare | 25 pts |
| Bronze | Hey Mr. Tallyman | Trade a total of 100,000 barrels manually | 10.3% Rare | 25 pts |
| Bronze | There, I Fixed It! | Perform an emergency repair | 11% Rare | 24 pts |
| Bronze | Treasure Hunter | Find a treasure with the help of a treasure map | 11.8% Rare | 23 pts |
| Bronze | The Message Is Trading, Dude! | A trading route has been active for 365 days | 13.2% Rare | 21 pts |
| Bronze | Always Welcome | Attain the highest reputation in one nation | 13.8% Rare | 21 pts |
| Bronze | Christening | Name a convoy | 14.9% Rare | 20 pts |
| Bronze | Clean Slate | Highest fame as 'Trader' | 15.1% Rare | 20 pts |
| Bronze | Arrr! | First successful boarding of a vessel | 15.7% Rare | 19 pts |
| Bronze | As Requested | 10 tasks fulfilled | 17.9% Rare | 18 pts |
| Bronze | True Hero | Attain the highest popularity in a town | 19.4% Rare | 17 pts |
| Bronze | Wistfulness | First vessel sold | 20.1% Uncommon | 17 pts |
| Bronze | Walk The Plank | Destroy a pirate convoy | 22.4% Uncommon | 15 pts |
| Bronze | Plundering | Ambush a trader | 24.2% Uncommon | 15 pts |
| Bronze | Ship Ahoy! | First naval battle | 29.5% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | Kudos! | Tutorial completed successfully | 29.7% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | Got Ye New Ship | Purchased first vessel | 37.8% Uncommon | 11 pts |
| Bronze | Welcome To The CArrrrribbean | First time at sea | 60.9% Common | 9 pts |