| Platinum | All Trophies Earned | Earn all trophies. | 0.1% Ultra Rare | 4,777 pts |
| Silver | Immortalized | Enter the HOF against 3 CPU opponents using both AI and Game immortal difficulties in MyGM. | 0.1% Ultra Rare | 1,791 pts |
| Bronze | Canceled | Have a GM earn the "Canceled" Slammy in MyGM. | 0.1% Ultra Rare | 1,194 pts |
| Bronze | Brown Noser | Complete every commissioner goal in a season and end in first place against 3 CPU opponents in MyGM. | 0.1% Ultra Rare | 1,194 pts |
| Bronze | Ring of Fire | Book a 5 star inferno match that includes the Red Flame defeating Ace Backdraft in MyGM | 0.1% Ultra Rare | 1,194 pts |
| Bronze | Mr. Perfect | Book a show with five, 5 star matches during a normal or Go-Home show in MyGM. | 0.1% Ultra Rare | 1,194 pts |
| Bronze | Perfect 15 | Perform Avalanche Pedigree Super Finisher 15 Times in Showcase. | 0.2% Ultra Rare | 788 pts |
| Bronze | Tag Champs | Book a intergender match with a male and female tag champion on the same team and win in MyGM. | 0.2% Ultra Rare | 788 pts |
| Bronze | Squash The Beef | Resolve 4 rivalries in a single match in MyGM. | 0.2% Ultra Rare | 788 pts |
| Bronze | RKO Everybody | Using Randy Orton, successfully RKO 26 different opponents on Legend difficulty (Play Mode vs AI). | 0.3% Ultra Rare | 618 pts |
| Bronze | Heist of the Century | Successfully cash in a Money in the Bank briefcase during the main event of WrestleMania in Universe | 0.4% Ultra Rare | 520 pts |
| Bronze | No Bread, No Water, Just Meat | As Oba Femi, win an 8-Way Battle Royal vs. seven Powerhouses on Legend difficulty (Play Mode vs AI). | 0.4% Ultra Rare | 520 pts |
| Silver | United States Champion | Complete all of the USA matches in World Tour in MyFACTION. | 0.5% Ultra Rare | 682 pts |
| Bronze | Rise Through the Ranks | Earn a Leaderboard Reward from a Ranked Play Season. | 0.5% Ultra Rare | 455 pts |
| Bronze | The Big E Payback | As Big E, pin or submit New Day in a 1-On-2 Handicap Match on Legend difficulty (Play Mode vs AI). | 0.5% Ultra Rare | 455 pts |
| Bronze | AvengeHer | Using Chelsea Green, defeat Michin in a Dumpster Match on Legend difficulty (Play Mode vs AI). | 0.5% Ultra Rare | 455 pts |
| Bronze | Faction Wars Champion | Defeat 30 Faction Wars Bosses in MyFACTION. | 0.5% Ultra Rare | 455 pts |
| Bronze | First Time For Everything | As Rhea Ripley, defeat Iyo Sky in a 15-Minute Iron Man match on Legend difficulty (Play Mode vs AI). | 0.5% Ultra Rare | 455 pts |
| Bronze | Beginner's Luck | Complete ALL Intro Challenges in MyFACTION. | 0.7% Ultra Rare | 372 pts |
| Bronze | Breaking Point ‘09 Revisited | Using Randy Orton, defeat John Cena in an I Quit Match on Legend difficulty (Play Mode vs AI). | 0.7% Ultra Rare | 372 pts |
| Bronze | Judge, Jury and Executioner | Win a lawsuit in MyGM. | 0.8% Ultra Rare | 343 pts |
| Bronze | Anytime, Anywhere | Initiate and win a brawl started from the ‘Post-Match Interview’ Promo Rival Action in Universe. | 0.9% Ultra Rare | 320 pts |
| Bronze | To Hell and Back | Win a 3 Stages of Hell match advancing through all 3 stages on Legend difficulty (Play Mode vs AI). | 1.4% Ultra Rare | 245 pts |
| Bronze | Burnt To A Crisp | Win an Inferno Match on Legend difficulty (Play Mode vs AI). | 1.5% Ultra Rare | 235 pts |
| Bronze | Someone Check On Booker | Using Stephanie Vaquer, successfully perform Devil’s Kiss. (Play Mode vs AI). | 1.7% Ultra Rare | 218 pts |
| Bronze | Back on Top | Regain your Championship in MyRISE. | 1.9% Ultra Rare | 204 pts |
| Bronze | It's Just Like I Remember | In CAA apply a WWE Apron, Mat, or Announce Table Material. | 2.3% Ultra Rare | 182 pts |
| Bronze | Watch Party | Use the Watch Show option to spectate a total of 5 matches in Universe. | 2.4% Ultra Rare | 177 pts |
| Gold | Comeback Again | Complete a playthrough of Both the Men's Division and Women's Division stories. | 2.7% Ultra Rare | 331 pts |
| Bronze | Start of the Journey | Complete a Location World Tour in MyFACTION. | 2.7% Ultra Rare | 165 pts |
| Bronze | Triangulated Approach | Perform a successful corner springboard attack to ringside on any difficulty (Play Mode vs AI). | 2.8% Ultra Rare | 162 pts |
| Bronze | Never Felt More A-LIVE | Win 10 LIVE Events in MyFACTION. | 2.9% Ultra Rare | 158 pts |
| Bronze | Chop it Up | Create a Champ, double champ or MITB custom entrance using the timeline. | 3.2% Ultra Rare | 149 pts |
| Bronze | A New Era | During a Draft, draft a Champion from one show to another in Universe. | 3.5% Ultra Rare | 141 pts |
| Bronze | Weekly Winner | Complete a Weekly Tower in MyFACTION. | 3.5% Ultra Rare | 141 pts |
| Bronze | Loyalty Confirmed | Earn a Loyalty Reward in MyFACTION. | 4.1% Ultra Rare | 129 pts |
| Silver | Bad Times Don't Last, Bad Guys Do | Remain a Rule Breaker throughout an Entire MyRISE Playthrough. | 4.2% Ultra Rare | 190 pts |
| Silver | Journey of a Lifetime | Complete 15 Lifetime Challenges in MyFACTION. | 4.8% Ultra Rare | 176 pts |
| Bronze | Brand Loyalty | During a Draft, pick a Superstar as a reserve for the show they’re already assigned to in Universe. | 5% Very Rare | 114 pts |
| Silver | A Hero's Journey | Remain a Fan Favorite Throughout an Entire MyRISE playthrough. | 5.9% Very Rare | 155 pts |
| Bronze | Mixed Matched | Use a female and male superstar in a match in MyFACTION. | 6.7% Very Rare | 96 pts |
| Bronze | Explosive Chemistry | Score 3 Chemistry Points in MyFACTION | 6.7% Very Rare | 96 pts |
| Bronze | The Wise Choice | Align with Paul Heyman in MyRISE. | 7.7% Very Rare | 88 pts |
| Silver | Nice Guys Finish First | Complete either the Men's or Women's story as a Fan Favorite in MyRISE. | 8.9% Very Rare | 121 pts |
| Silver | Best in the World | Complete All Objectives in Showcase or beat the Gauntlet. | 9.4% Very Rare | 117 pts |
| Bronze | Who's Next? | Defend your Championship in MyRISE. | 9.9% Very Rare | 76 pts |
| Silver | Showcase of the Immortals | Complete either the Men's or Women's story as a Rule Breaker in MyRISE. | 10.2% Rare | 112 pts |
| Bronze | Everyone’s Got A Job To Do | Lose any 5-star rated match via pinfall or submission (Play Mode vs AI). | 10.7% Rare | 72 pts |
| Bronze | No Oracle Needed | Reject Paul Heyman in MyRISE. | 11.3% Rare | 70 pts |
| Bronze | What if? | Finish “What If” Section in Showcase. | 11.5% Rare | 69 pts |
| Bronze | Heel-ing Power | Choose the Initial Rule Breaker Path in MyRISE | 12.6% Rare | 66 pts |
| Bronze | Change History | Prevent the Montreal Screwjob in Showcase. | 14.3% Rare | 61 pts |
| Bronze | In the Blender | Create a Superstar with a blended body. | 19.1% Rare | 51 pts |
| Bronze | Streak Breaker | End The Streak at WrestleMania 29 in Showcase. | 19.2% Rare | 51 pts |
| Bronze | A Promising Start | Complete a Lifetime Challenge in MyFACTION. | 19.5% Rare | 50 pts |
| Bronze | RISE Up | Earn 5 Stars in a Single RISE Match | 20.7% Uncommon | 49 pts |
| Bronze | Face the Music | Choose the Initial Fan Favorite Path in MyRISE | 22.5% Uncommon | 46 pts |
| Bronze | One Down... | Complete One Objective in Showcase. | 29.9% Uncommon | 39 pts |