| Platinum | Sisu | Gain all trophies | 5.6% Very Rare | 142 pts |
| Bronze | Hidden by the Trees | Find all Cult Stashes and Lunch Boxes | 9.4% Very Rare | 26 pts |
| Bronze | Rustic Charm | Find all the Charms | 9.4% Very Rare | 26 pts |
| Bronze | Shift in Reality | Complete all Nursery Rhyme puzzles | 11% Rare | 24 pts |
| Bronze | I'll Find You | Find all Nursery Rhyme dolls | 11.2% Rare | 23 pts |
| Bronze | Coffee-Themed Fun | Shoot Mr. Drippy or any other cardboard cutout in Coffee World | 11.5% Rare | 23 pts |
| Bronze | All Smiles | Fully upgrade a single weapon | 12.9% Rare | 22 pts |
| Bronze | The Nice Things in Life | Pet Mayor Setter | 13.2% Rare | 21 pts |
| Bronze | Back to Life | Use a Coffee Mug Charm to prevent defeat | 17% Rare | 18 pts |
| Bronze | The Koskela Brothers | Watch all Koskela brother commercials | 18.3% Rare | 17 pts |
| Bronze | Gone for Good | Defeat an enemy with an explosion | 24% Uncommon | 15 pts |
| Bronze | All Accounted For | Find all weapons for both characters | 24.5% Uncommon | 15 pts |
| Bronze | The Trail of the Writer | Watch all the Writer's Journey videos | 25.6% Uncommon | 14 pts |
| Bronze | Strange Reality | Solve five Nursery Rhyme puzzles | 27.3% Uncommon | 14 pts |
| Bronze | Stunning Vistas | Stun an enemy with a Flashbang | 27.6% Uncommon | 14 pts |
| Silver | The Story Come True | Complete Alan Wake 2 | 28.2% Uncommon | 20 pts |
| Bronze | End of the Road | Complete chapter "Come Home" | 28.2% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | The Final Deerfest | Complete chapter "Deerfest" | 28.3% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | Filled with Rage | Defeat Scratch | 28.4% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | Rock n' Roll, Baby | Complete chapter "Summoning" | 28.4% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | His Way Out | Complete chapter "Gone" | 28.5% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | Ready for a Fight | Find the Hunting Rifle | 28.7% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | Stop Right There | Find the Pump-Action Shotgun | 29.3% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | The Cult of the Word | Complete chapter "Zane's Film" | 29.7% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | Seeing Double | Complete chapter "Scratch" | 30.8% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | Behind the Masks | Complete chapter "Masks" | 30.8% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | In One Go | Defeat an enemy with a single shot from the Crossbow | 30.9% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | Told and Retold | Complete chapter "Return" | 31.3% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | The Old Gods | Complete chapter "Old Gods" | 31.9% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | Girl in Love | Defeat Cynthia | 31.9% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | Cut Short | Find the Boltcutters | 32% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | In a Fancy Hotel | Complete chapter "Room 665" | 32.1% Uncommon | 12 pts |
| Bronze | This is the Moment | Dodge at the last minute to avoid an enemy attack | 33.5% Uncommon | 12 pts |
| Bronze | We Watch in the Night | Complete chapter "No Chance" | 33.9% Uncommon | 12 pts |
| Bronze | Escape its Gravity | Use a Hand Flare to escape an enemy Grapple | 33.9% Uncommon | 12 pts |
| Bronze | Yippee Ki-yay | Find the Double-Barrelled Shotgun | 34.1% Uncommon | 12 pts |
| Bronze | Filling the Shape | Place a Charm in all of the bracelet's slots | 34.6% Uncommon | 12 pts |
| Bronze | Bright Falls' Finest | Defeat Mulligan and Thornton | 35% Uncommon | 12 pts |
| Bronze | All His Life | Complete chapter "We Sing" | 35% Uncommon | 12 pts |
| Bronze | Back in Watery | Complete chapter "Local Girl" | 35% Uncommon | 12 pts |
| Bronze | Stop the Monster | Interrupt a Taken Thrower's relocation attempt with the Flashlight Boost | 35.1% Uncommon | 12 pts |
| Bronze | Lights Shining | Find the Flare Gun | 35.3% Uncommon | 12 pts |
| Bronze | Greatest Hits | Find the Crossbow | 35.5% Uncommon | 12 pts |
| Bronze | Finding a Way | Find the Screwdriver | 36.8% Uncommon | 11 pts |
| Bronze | Growing Stronger | Upgrade any weapon once | 37.1% Uncommon | 11 pts |
| Bronze | Shining in the Night | Ignite a Hand Flare to keep enemies at bay | 38.7% Uncommon | 11 pts |
| Bronze | The Other Side | Change between stories once | 40.3% Common | 11 pts |
| Bronze | Return | Complete chapter "Haunting" | 40.4% Common | 11 pts |
| Bronze | Storm Cloud | Escape from the Dark Presence | 40.7% Common | 11 pts |
| Bronze | New York City | Complete chapter "Casey" | 40.7% Common | 11 pts |
| Bronze | Carry his Words | Discover a Word of Power | 45.1% Common | 10 pts |
| Bronze | Aimed Ahead | Defeat five enemies with headshots | 46.1% Common | 10 pts |
| Bronze | Find the Light | Find the Flashlight and Revolver | 48.2% Common | 10 pts |
| Bronze | Talk Show | Complete chapter "Late Night" | 49.5% Common | 10 pts |
| Bronze | Lawman | Defeat Nightingale | 54.8% Common | 9 pts |
| Bronze | Into the Overlap | Complete chapter "The Heart" | 54.8% Common | 9 pts |
| Bronze | Felt Good | Use a Healing Item | 55.7% Common | 9 pts |
| Bronze | Bring It | Find the Sawed-Off Shotgun | 55.8% Common | 9 pts |
| Bronze | Chased the Source | Destroy a Source Point | 57.2% Common | 9 pts |
| Bronze | Grew Bigger | Upgrade the inventory's size | 57.5% Common | 9 pts |
| Bronze | Darkness Coiled | Destroy a Darkness Shield | 57.9% Common | 9 pts |
| Bronze | Coffee Thermos | Discover a Break Room | 59.2% Common | 9 pts |
| Bronze | Secret Stashes | Discover one Cult Stash and one Lunch Box | 59.3% Common | 9 pts |
| Bronze | Somebody's Home | Complete chapter "Invitation" | 64.1% Common | 8 pts |
| Bronze | Not the Last | Pick up the first Manuscript Page | 72.9% Common | 8 pts |
| Bronze | Nightmare Territory | Pick up a map | 87.4% Common | 7 pts |
| Bronze | Hunting Season | Complete chapter "The Cult" | 90.4% Common | 7 pts |