| Platinum | Platinum Trophy | You've unlocked all of the trophies! | 3.4% Ultra Rare | 576 pts |
| Gold | All the Cheevos! | Completed 180 Optional Objectives | 4.1% Ultra Rare | 257 pts |
| Gold | Ultra Extreme Objectification | Completed 150 Optional Objectives | 5% Very Rare | 228 pts |
| Gold | Cryptic Cryptid | Completed every Celestial Realm trial | 6.4% Very Rare | 197 pts |
| Silver | Extreme Objectification | Completed 120 Optional Objectives | 6.4% Very Rare | 148 pts |
| Silver | Half-Way Yay! | Completed 90 Optional Objectives | 9% Very Rare | 120 pts |
| Silver | Grounded | Completed every trial in Gnorman's Gneighborhood | 9.1% Very Rare | 120 pts |
| Silver | Trials and Some Tribulations | Completed every trial in the Gravely Grove | 10.1% Rare | 112 pts |
| Silver | SSSSlide | Completed every trial in Winter Blunderland | 13.1% Rare | 96 pts |
| Silver | Higher Ground | Completed every trial in Mountain Highs | 13.2% Rare | 96 pts |
| Silver | Baller | Won a level with at least 12 balls left (Except Trials and Multiplayer) | 13.2% Rare | 96 pts |
| Bronze | Objection! | Completed 60 Optional Objectives | 14.8% Rare | 60 pts |
| Silver | Orange Crusher | Hit 5000 orange pegs | 16.9% Rare | 83 pts |
| Gold | Peggle Master | Completed every Celestial Realm level | 19.3% Rare | 102 pts |
| Silver | Every Day I'm Pegglin' | Hit 10000 blue pegs | 21% Uncommon | 72 pts |
| Silver | I'd Hit That | Hit 300 green pegs | 21.1% Uncommon | 72 pts |
| Silver | Institutionalized | Completed every trial in the Peggle Institute | 21.3% Uncommon | 72 pts |
| Silver | Coolest Clear | Won a level with the cool clear style shot (Except Trials and Multiplayer) | 21.9% Uncommon | 71 pts |
| Silver | Not Too Scary | Completed every level in Gravely Grove | 38.3% Uncommon | 51 pts |
| Bronze | Opt-in | Completed 30 Optional Objectives | 39.1% Uncommon | 33 pts |
| Silver | Found So Many Contraptions | Completed every level in Gnorman's Gneighborhood | 44.6% Common | 46 pts |
| Silver | Found Frozen Friends | Completed every level in Winter Blunderland | 50% Common | 43 pts |
| Silver | Ultra Extreme Fever | Cleared all pegs in a level (Singleplayer Only) | 51.7% Common | 42 pts |
| Silver | Trolled | Completed every level in Mountain Highs | 58.6% Common | 39 pts |
| Bronze | Superior Shot | Earned 3 free balls on one shot (Except Trials and Multiplayer) | 61.6% Common | 25 pts |
| Silver | Toured the Campus | Completed every level in the Peggle Institute | 72.1% Common | 35 pts |
| Bronze | Ace'd! | Beat your first ace score | 76.2% Common | 22 pts |
| Bronze | Stylin' | Got 75,000 styleshot points in a shot (Except Trials and Multiplayer) | 78.1% Common | 22 pts |
| Bronze | I Got a Fever | Cleared all orange pegs in a level (Singleplayer Only) | 91.5% Common | 20 pts |