| Platinum | 200.60% | Got every other trophy in the game | 6% Very Rare | 137 pts |
| Gold | Overlooked | Never captured by The Presence | 7.2% Very Rare | 61 pts |
| Gold | Touching | Found every touchstone | 7.3% Very Rare | 61 pts |
| Bronze | Van Hout Memento | Found all touchstones in Chapter 2 | 7.9% Very Rare | 29 pts |
| Bronze | Giddy Socialite | Found Kirby | 7.9% Very Rare | 29 pts |
| Bronze | Kicked | Found 5 backer letters | 8.3% Very Rare | 28 pts |
| Gold | Quiet Knoll | Completed without tapping | 9.6% Very Rare | 51 pts |
| Silver | Like It's Hot 3 | Found 2 Poppets in Chapter 3 | 9.8% Very Rare | 38 pts |
| Bronze | Lloyd | Best damn bartender | 10.3% Rare | 25 pts |
| Bronze | Maximized | What we do in life... | 10.5% Rare | 24 pts |
| Gold | The Doll Collector | Found every poppet | 11.2% Rare | 47 pts |
| Bronze | I Hear Things Out Here | Found out what happened to the animals | 12.8% Rare | 22 pts |
| Bronze | Briar Memento | Found all touchstones in Chapter 1 | 14.4% Rare | 20 pts |
| Bronze | Still Doing This | Is it going to get old? | 14.5% Rare | 20 pts |
| Bronze | Bosch Memento | Found all touchstones in Chapter 3 | 14.8% Rare | 20 pts |
| Bronze | Backed | Found the backer recordings | 16.1% Rare | 19 pts |
| Silver | Like It's Hot 1 | Found 2 Poppets in Chapter 1 | 16.4% Rare | 28 pts |
| Bronze | Durham Memento | Found all touchstones in Chapter 4 | 20.3% Uncommon | 16 pts |
| Bronze | Ceres | The galaxy is at peace | 20.8% Uncommon | 16 pts |
| Bronze | Snoop | Listened to all of Cassie's messages | 22.2% Uncommon | 16 pts |
| Silver | Like It's Hot 4 | Found 2 Poppets in Chapter 4 | 22.3% Uncommon | 23 pts |
| Silver | Like It's Hot 2 | Found 2 Poppets in Chapter 2 | 25.7% Uncommon | 21 pts |
| Silver | Fire | Completed Chapter 4 | 25.8% Uncommon | 21 pts |
| Gold | Spirit | Completed every chapter | 26.7% Uncommon | 28 pts |
| Bronze | For Susannah | Found Susannah's sanctum | 26.9% Uncommon | 14 pts |
| Silver | Earth | Completed Chapter 3 | 27.8% Uncommon | 20 pts |
| Silver | Water | Completed Chapter 2 | 34.7% Uncommon | 18 pts |
| Bronze | Behind You... | Turn around... | 36.6% Uncommon | 12 pts |
| Bronze | Tickled Pink | Listened to every Dearest Pinky song | 40.7% Common | 11 pts |
| Bronze | Mashi | Found Nanci Chang's takeout menu | 43.4% Common | 10 pts |
| Silver | Wind | Completed Chapter 1 | 50.9% Common | 14 pts |
| Bronze | Master of... | Got the key from the good Doctor | 65.7% Common | 8 pts |