| Platinum | Earn All Trophies | Earn All Trophies | 0.3% Ultra Rare | 824 pts |
| Bronze | One Team Player | Retire after playing your whole Pro career at 1 AFL club | 0.3% Ultra Rare | 206 pts |
| Bronze | Heritage | Play a match with every AFL Heritage Guernsey | 0.3% Ultra Rare | 206 pts |
| Gold | Silverware | In Competition win every competition trophy (Hard+) | 0.4% Ultra Rare | 347 pts |
| Silver | Wise Head | Reach level 50 as a rookie Pro Career player | 0.5% Ultra Rare | 227 pts |
| Silver | AFL Veteran | Reach profile level 50 | 0.6% Ultra Rare | 204 pts |
| Bronze | Hall of Famer | Play all seasons in Career mode | 0.8% Ultra Rare | 114 pts |
| Bronze | Bragging Rights | Win 5 online matches in a row | 1% Ultra Rare | 100 pts |
| Silver | Sharp Shooter | In a season kick 30 goals in a row without missing | 1.2% Ultra Rare | 134 pts |
| Silver | Total Domination | Finish a season top of the AFL ladder with no losses (Hard+) | 1.3% Ultra Rare | 128 pts |
| Bronze | Old Hand | Reach level 30 as a rookie Pro Career player | 2.3% Ultra Rare | 61 pts |
| Bronze | Tackle Fest | Perform more than 50 tackles in one match | 2.6% Ultra Rare | 56 pts |
| Bronze | AFL Free Agent | Reach profile level 30 | 2.6% Ultra Rare | 56 pts |
| Gold | Back to Back to Back | In a Career, win 3 AFL Premierships in a row (Medium+) | 2.8% Ultra Rare | 108 pts |
| Bronze | Cream of the Crop | In Coach Career, have a footballer achieve a 95 overall rating | 3.1% Ultra Rare | 51 pts |
| Silver | Premiership Quarter | Come from behind to lead at the end of the 3rd quarter in an AFL Grand Final (Hard+) | 3.3% Ultra Rare | 73 pts |
| Silver | I See It But I Do Not Believe It | Come from 50 points down to win (Medium+) | 3.9% Ultra Rare | 66 pts |
| Bronze | The Kid Has Potential | In Pro Career win the NAB Rising Star | 5.6% Very Rare | 36 pts |
| Bronze | Local Heroes | Win a VFL Premiership | 5.7% Very Rare | 35 pts |
| Bronze | Lockett End | Kick more than 1360 goals | 5.9% Very Rare | 34 pts |
| Silver | 200 Club | Complete 200 season objectives across multiple Career seasons | 6% Very Rare | 51 pts |
| Bronze | Complete Player | Complete a total of 200 match objectives | 6% Very Rare | 34 pts |
| Silver | Chas | In Coach Career, a player on your team wins the Brownlow Medal (Medium+) | 8.3% Very Rare | 42 pts |
| Bronze | Down to the Wire | Score the winning goal from a set shot after the final siren | 8.6% Very Rare | 28 pts |
| Bronze | Back to the Drawing Board | Lose an AFL Grand Final | 8.7% Very Rare | 27 pts |
| Bronze | Ball Sense | Reach level 15 as a rookie Pro Career player | 9.9% Very Rare | 25 pts |
| Bronze | Leadership Group | In Pro Career become captain of your team (Medium+) | 10.7% Rare | 24 pts |
| Silver | BOG | In Pro Career win the Norm Smith Medal in an AFL Grand Final | 10.8% Rare | 36 pts |
| Bronze | AFL Rookie | Reach profile level 15 | 11.4% Rare | 23 pts |
| Bronze | Expansion Granted | Complete a match using a custom team. | 11.8% Rare | 23 pts |
| Bronze | Networking | Complete an online match | 17.2% Rare | 18 pts |
| Bronze | Cannot Separate Them | Draw a match | 18.2% Rare | 18 pts |
| Bronze | The Big League | In Pro Career accept a contract offer to play in the AFL | 20.4% Uncommon | 16 pts |
| Silver | Double Chance | Finish top 4 in a regular AFL season (Medium+) | 20.9% Uncommon | 24 pts |
| Bronze | Are You Experienced? | In Pro Career play a match as a listed player | 21.5% Uncommon | 16 pts |
| Bronze | Learning The Ropes | Reach level 5 as a rookie Pro Career player | 25.3% Uncommon | 14 pts |
| Bronze | On A String | Achieve 40 disposals with 1 player in a match | 27.9% Uncommon | 14 pts |
| Bronze | One Game at a Time | Win an AFL Premiership | 29.4% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | The Barrel | Kick a torpedo goal 60 meters out | 30.3% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | Grubby | Kick a Grubber Goal | 34.3% Uncommon | 12 pts |
| Bronze | Rookie Choice | In Pro Career create a Rookie and play a match | 43% Common | 10 pts |
| Bronze | AFL Novice | Reach profile level 5 | 44.5% Common | 10 pts |
| Bronze | New Recruit | Complete a match using a custom created player. | 45.3% Common | 10 pts |
| Bronze | Footy is Back! | Complete the JLT Community Series | 49.7% Common | 10 pts |
| Bronze | A Day Out | Kick 10 goals with one player in a match | 49.7% Common | 10 pts |
| Bronze | Delicious! | Take a Speckie | 51.1% Common | 9 pts |
| Bronze | Coast To Coast | From a kick-in, score a goal without the opposition touching the ball | 59.2% Common | 9 pts |
| Bronze | Single Minded | Complete all of your match objectives during a match. | 59.8% Common | 9 pts |
| Bronze | Having a Shocker | Kick the ball out on the full 3 times in a match | 74.3% Common | 8 pts |
| Bronze | Putting On A Clinic | Have 6 or more goal scorers in a match | 74.6% Common | 8 pts |
| Bronze | Woodwork | Hit the post | 84.7% Common | 7 pts |