| Platinum | Platinum Trophy | Unlocked when all trophies collected. | 1.3% Ultra Rare | 1,025 pts |
| Silver | Collector's Edition | You have found every manuscript page in the game. | 1.4% Ultra Rare | 368 pts |
| Bronze | Alan, Wake Up | You completed the game on Nightmare difficulty. | 1.5% Ultra Rare | 235 pts |
| Gold | Bright Falls Aficionado | You have examined every sign and point of interest in the Bright Falls area. | 1.6% Ultra Rare | 453 pts |
| Silver | Hypercaffeinated | You have discovered every thermos of coffee. | 1.6% Ultra Rare | 339 pts |
| Bronze | Meet the Deadline | You made it all the way to the Cauldron Lake lookout in under 30 minutes. | 1.6% Ultra Rare | 226 pts |
| Bronze | Gunless Wonder | You managed to make it all the way from the dam to Cauldron Lake without firing a single bullet. | 1.7% Ultra Rare | 218 pts |
| Bronze | Every Nook and Cranny | You have discovered all of the hidden chests. | 1.7% Ultra Rare | 218 pts |
| Silver | Picking Up After Yourself | You have found every manuscript page in Normal mode. | 1.8% Ultra Rare | 316 pts |
| Bronze | An Idyllic Small Town | You fought your way through the streets of Bright Falls without getting killed. | 3% Ultra Rare | 155 pts |
| Gold | Couch Potato | You have watched every single TV show on offer. | 3.8% Ultra Rare | 269 pts |
| Bronze | Carny | You have heartlessly knocked over five defenseless can pyramids. | 4.3% Ultra Rare | 125 pts |
| Bronze | Medical Opinions | You listened to Hartman's recordings. | 4.5% Ultra Rare | 122 pts |
| Bronze | Taken Season | You have dropped 50 Taken with the hunting rifle. | 4.8% Ultra Rare | 117 pts |
| Gold | KBF-FM | You haven't missed a single radio show. | 5.8% Very Rare | 209 pts |
| Bronze | Child of the Elder God | You shone a light upon this night of otherworldly fiends. | 6.1% Very Rare | 101 pts |
| Bronze | If It Flies, It Burns | Not a bird lover, are you? | 7.9% Very Rare | 87 pts |
| Bronze | Boob Tube | You checked out some important messages. | 8.3% Very Rare | 84 pts |
| Bronze | Drink 'Em Both Up | You drank 'em bot' up. | 10% Rare | 75 pts |
| Bronze | Hardboiled Writer | You completed the game on Normal difficulty. | 11.2% Rare | 70 pts |
| Bronze | What Light Through Yonder Window | It is the east, and the flaregun is the sun to 50 Taken. | 14.4% Rare | 61 pts |
| Bronze | Right of Way | You have peeled 15 Taken off your bumper. | 14.5% Rare | 60 pts |
| Bronze | Departure | You completed the game on Easy difficulty. | 17.2% Rare | 54 pts |
| Bronze | Tornado Wrangler | You calmed the fury of the storm. | 17.2% Rare | 54 pts |
| Bronze | Heavy Metal | You destroyed the bulldozer. | 17.3% Rare | 54 pts |
| Bronze | The Lady of the Light | Cynthia Weaver has taken you to the Well-Lit Room. | 18.1% Rare | 53 pts |
| Bronze | Gatekeeper | Truly, you are the master of floodgates. | 18.2% Rare | 53 pts |
| Bronze | Iron Horse | You made the train engine run out of steam. | 18.6% Rare | 52 pts |
| Bronze | It's Not Just a Typewriter Brand | QWERTY? DVORAK? 50 Taken know it's neither. | 19% Rare | 51 pts |
| Bronze | Perchance to Dream | Oh, so THAT'S what happened. | 19.1% Rare | 51 pts |
| Bronze | Come One, Come All | You wiped out four Taken with a single flare. | 19.3% Rare | 51 pts |
| Bronze | Thunder and Lightning | 50 Taken have felt your fury. Also, your flashbangs. | 19.6% Rare | 50 pts |
| Bronze | Two For the Price of One | You took out two Taken with a single barrel. | 20.6% Uncommon | 49 pts |
| Bronze | Collateral Carnage | 20 Taken have been drowned, electrocuted, or dispatched by some other indirect means. | 20.7% Uncommon | 49 pts |
| Bronze | Energized! | You changed batteries 100 times. | 21.1% Uncommon | 48 pts |
| Bronze | Wheels Within Wheels | You found the kidnapper, but what he had to say wasn't what you wanted to hear. | 21.4% Uncommon | 48 pts |
| Bronze | They're Heeeeeere! | You have destroyed 20 poltergeist objects. | 21.9% Uncommon | 47 pts |
| Bronze | The Six-Gun Scribe | You capped 100 Taken with the revolver. | 22.1% Uncommon | 47 pts |
| Silver | Damn Good Cup of Coffee | You have found 25 coffee thermoses. | 22.6% Uncommon | 69 pts |
| Bronze | Sound and Fury | You blasted four Taken into ashes with a single flashbang. | 22.7% Uncommon | 46 pts |
| Bronze | Finders Keepers | You have discovered five of the hidden chests. | 23.4% Uncommon | 45 pts |
| Bronze | Missed by a Mile | You managed a slow-motion dodge 20 times. | 24.3% Uncommon | 44 pts |
| Silver | Paging Mr. Wake | You have discovered 25 manuscript pages. | 27.1% Uncommon | 62 pts |
| Bronze | Park Ranger | You survived Elderwood National Park. | 27.5% Uncommon | 41 pts |
| Bronze | Back! Back, I Say! | You bought yourself some breathing time with a flare. | 28.4% Uncommon | 40 pts |
| Bronze | Under a Thin Layer of Skin | You disobeyed the park ranger's instructions. | 38.3% Uncommon | 34 pts |
| Bronze | Bright Falls' Finest | You finally managed to make that phone call. | 44.3% Common | 31 pts |
| Bronze | Nordic Walking | Unlike Stucky, you enjoy incontestable health benefits. Namely, you're not dead. | 45.1% Common | 31 pts |
| Bronze | Float Like a Butterfly | You avoided getting hit -- with style! | 57.7% Common | 26 pts |
| Bronze | Let There Be Light | You have restored power. | 62.7% Common | 25 pts |
| Bronze | Follow the Light | You were enlightened by a dream. | 84.9% Common | 21 pts |