| Platinum | There's Also A World Inside of Me. | Unlock all other trophies | 67.6% Common | 32 pts |
| Gold | How May I Help You? | Choose to pick up the phone. | 69.4% Common | 16 pts |
| Gold | There's The Whole World Out There | Choose to not pick up the phone. | 69.9% Common | 16 pts |
| Gold | Everyday Felt Like Halloween | Complete the Fall puzzle level. | 71.7% Common | 15 pts |
| Gold | Superstitious or Ambitious | Get past the ghouls and ghosts. | 71.9% Common | 15 pts |
| Gold | I Used to Not Worry About Any of This | Complete the Summer puzzle level. | 73.2% Common | 15 pts |
| Gold | That's A Feeling I've Forgotten | Learn that not all people will accept what they can't see. | 75% Common | 15 pts |
| Gold | I Can't Ever Lose You | Complete the Spring puzzle level. | 75.7% Common | 15 pts |
| Gold | You Are So Important To Me | Find Sunny in the Grocery Store. | 76.6% Common | 15 pts |
| Silver | Bentley, What Have We Done? | Complete the Winter puzzle level. | 84.1% Common | 11 pts |
| Gold | I Was Just Having Fun | Turn on Bentley's light. | 84.2% Common | 14 pts |
| Gold | Is This A Dream? | Try to take the shortcut in the jungle but get stopped by the tree. | 85.8% Common | 14 pts |
| Silver | I Could Be Me I Could Be You | Complete the Bedroom puzzle level. | 88.3% Common | 10 pts |
| Silver | I Was Free I Was New | Make it through the kitchen despite being so small. | 88.9% Common | 10 pts |
| Silver | I'm Not Even Supposed to Be Here! | Turn on the generator in the basement of the office. | 92.7% Common | 10 pts |