| Platinum | Football Legend | Unlock all other trophies (excluding additional content trophies) | 0.1% Ultra Rare | 4,777 pts |
| Bronze | Growing Club | Achieve a club value of 85,000,000 in FIFA 12 Ultimate Team | 0.2% Ultra Rare | 788 pts |
| Bronze | All My Own Work | Win a Match with Manual Controls (including Tactical Defending) | 0.5% Ultra Rare | 455 pts |
| Gold | Pack King | Open 100 packs in FIFA 12 Ultimate Team | 1.3% Ultra Rare | 513 pts |
| Silver | "Big Cup" Squad | Enter an Ultimate Team tournament and finish a match with an overall squad rating of 85 or higher | 1.3% Ultra Rare | 384 pts |
| Bronze | Club Legend | Play 100 matches with any player in FIFA 12 Ultimate Team | 1.6% Ultra Rare | 226 pts |
| Silver | We'll need a larger trophy case | Win your 10th trophy in FIFA 12 Ultimate Team | 1.9% Ultra Rare | 306 pts |
| Silver | Marquee Signing | Purchase a Gold Player from the trade market for 15,000 or more coins using Buy now | 2.6% Ultra Rare | 254 pts |
| Bronze | Friendly | Finish a match against a Friend in FIFA 12 Ultimate Team | 4.9% Ultra Rare | 116 pts |
| Bronze | How Great is that? | Find a team of the week player in an Ultimate Team pack | 6.8% Very Rare | 95 pts |
| Bronze | Sweet Music | Set up some Custom Audio in FIFA 12 | 7.1% Very Rare | 93 pts |
| Silver | Legendary | Win a game vs. the CPU on legendary difficulty against a club of the same or higher star level | 7.8% Very Rare | 131 pts |
| Bronze | Friends now Enemies? | Win an Online Friendlies season | 8.4% Very Rare | 84 pts |
| Silver | Virtual Legend | Play 50 Matches with your Virtual Pro | 9.3% Very Rare | 118 pts |
| Bronze | Tournament Victory | Win a tournament in FIFA 12 Ultimate Team | 10.8% Rare | 72 pts |
| Bronze | Virtual Debut | Play an online Pro Club or Pro Ranked match with your Virtual Pro | 11.9% Rare | 68 pts |
| Bronze | Challenge Accepted | Complete an EA SPORTS Football Club Game Scenario Challenge | 13.6% Rare | 63 pts |
| Silver | FIFA for Life | Spend 50 hours on the pitch | 13.8% Rare | 93 pts |
| Bronze | Comeback Kid | Win after being down 3 goals in the 2nd half in a game vs. the CPU | 14.8% Rare | 60 pts |
| Bronze | Path to the Cup | Win a cup game in Head to Head Seasons | 16.4% Rare | 56 pts |
| Bronze | I'll have that one | Open your first pack in FIFA 12 Ultimate Team | 17.5% Rare | 54 pts |
| Silver | EAS FC Starting 11 | Reach level 20 in the EA SPORTS Football Club | 18.9% Rare | 77 pts |
| Silver | Trophy Time | Win the league title in any league in Career Mode | 19.1% Rare | 77 pts |
| Silver | Riding Bikes | Score with a bicycle kick | 19.6% Rare | 75 pts |
| Bronze | Legends start with Victories | Win a match with your FIFA 12 Ultimate Team club | 19.8% Rare | 50 pts |
| Silver | Youth is Served | Sign a player to your youth squad in Career Mode | 20.3% Uncommon | 74 pts |
| Bronze | Massive Signing | Sign a player better than anyone else on your club during the transfer window | 21.1% Uncommon | 48 pts |
| Bronze | Block Party | Manually block 5 shots while defending in a single game | 21.5% Uncommon | 48 pts |
| Bronze | 10 vs 11 | Win from a draw or behind while down a man in a game vs the CPU | 22.6% Uncommon | 46 pts |
| Bronze | Procrastinator | Sign a player on Deadline Day in the transfer window in Career Mode | 23.9% Uncommon | 45 pts |
| Bronze | Quickly Now! | Score shortly after a quick throw-in | 26% Uncommon | 42 pts |
| Bronze | Being Social | Play an Online Friendlies Match | 26.7% Uncommon | 42 pts |
| Bronze | Puppet Master | Talk to the Press in Career Mode | 28.5% Uncommon | 40 pts |
| Silver | Campaign Complete | Complete a Season in Head to Head Seasons | 29% Uncommon | 60 pts |
| Bronze | Precision Tackler | Obtain a successful tackle percentage of 80% with a minimum of 5 tackles in a game | 30.3% Uncommon | 39 pts |
| Bronze | New Club in Town | Create your FIFA 12 Ultimate Team club | 31.6% Uncommon | 38 pts |
| Bronze | 3 Points | Win a season game in Head to Head Seasons | 32% Uncommon | 38 pts |
| Bronze | No Draw for You! | Score a 90th minute winner in a game vs. the CPU | 32% Uncommon | 38 pts |
| Silver | Fully Formed | Have three players be in full form at the same time on your club in Career Mode | 35.4% Uncommon | 53 pts |
| Silver | Century of Goals | Score 100 goals in FIFA 12 match play | 40.2% Common | 49 pts |
| Bronze | Warrior | Score a goal after suffering a non-contact injury with a player | 42.9% Common | 31 pts |
| Bronze | EAS FC Youth Academy | Reach level 5 in the EA SPORTS Football Club | 45.6% Common | 30 pts |
| Bronze | Happy 20th EA SPORTS! | Score 20 match goals in FIFA 12 to celebrate 20 years of EA SPORTS! | 53.8% Common | 27 pts |
| Bronze | Don't Blink | Score within the first 5 minutes of a game in a game vs the CPU | 59.8% Common | 26 pts |
| Silver | Megged | Successfully dribble the ball through a defender's legs | 70.3% Common | 35 pts |
| Bronze | Ruud Boy | Score a goal on a volley | 76.1% Common | 22 pts |