| Platinum | Master Assassin | Get every trophy. | 0.6% Ultra Rare | 1,630 pts |
| Silver | Completionist | Complete ALL progress tracker grid entries. | 1% Ultra Rare | 450 pts |
| Bronze | Original Gamer | Win a game of Fanorona, Morris and Bowls on the Homestead. | 1.1% Ultra Rare | 283 pts |
| Bronze | Coureur des Bois | Exchange undamaged pelts at all different general stores. | 1.4% Ultra Rare | 245 pts |
| Silver | The Truth Will Out | Unlock a hacked version of one of the Abstergo videos in the story quest. | 1.7% Ultra Rare | 327 pts |
| Bronze | An Extraordinary Man | Complete the Encyclopedia of the Common Man. | 2.1% Ultra Rare | 192 pts |
| Silver | Perfectionist | Complete 100% of all main mission constraints. | 2.3% Ultra Rare | 273 pts |
| Silver | Head in the Cloud | Find all pivots and sync the Animus to the Cloud. | 2.7% Ultra Rare | 248 pts |
| Bronze | Prince of Thieves | Loot a convoy without killing any of its guards. | 2.7% Ultra Rare | 165 pts |
| Silver | In Good Standing | Complete all challenges for any of the Clubs. | 3.3% Ultra Rare | 220 pts |
| Silver | Abstergo Entertainment | Reach level 20 in the multiplayer mode. | 3.6% Ultra Rare | 209 pts |
| Bronze | Monopoly Man | Send a convoy to Boston, New York and the Frontier. | 4.1% Ultra Rare | 129 pts |
| Bronze | Hunter/Killer | Reach sequence 10 in a map on Wolfpack multiplayer mode. | 4.3% Ultra Rare | 125 pts |
| Bronze | Personalized | Customize your multiplayer Profile and Character. | 6% Very Rare | 102 pts |
| Bronze | Winning Team | Be on the winning team at the end of a multiplayer game session. | 7.5% Very Rare | 90 pts |
| Bronze | Patent Not Pending | Craft one of Franklin's inventions to decorate your Manor. | 8.6% Very Rare | 82 pts |
| Bronze | Predator | Hang 5 enemies by using rope darts. | 9.4% Very Rare | 78 pts |
| Bronze | Magna cum Laude | Have a Trainee reach the Assassin Rank. | 12.3% Rare | 67 pts |
| Bronze | Entrepreneur, not Pirate! | Complete all 12 Privateer Contracts. | 13.4% Rare | 63 pts |
| Bronze | Kidd Gloves | Uncover the mystery of Oak Island. | 13.6% Rare | 63 pts |
| Silver | All Washed Up | Complete all Naval Missions aboard the Aquila. | 16% Rare | 85 pts |
| Silver | A Complete Set | See all the optional characters settled at the Homestead. | 16.4% Rare | 84 pts |
| Bronze | Jager Bomb | After becoming fully Notorious, kill 10 Jagers before losing your notoriety. | 17.9% Rare | 53 pts |
| Bronze | Blowing in the Wind | Retrieve every page for one of Ben Franklin's Almanacs. | 18.6% Rare | 52 pts |
| Bronze | Multitasking | Complete 50% of the Progress Tracker entries. | 21.1% Uncommon | 48 pts |
| Silver | Man of the People | Liberate all districts in Boston OR New York. | 22.2% Uncommon | 70 pts |
| Bronze | Bring Down the House | Explore Fort Wolcott. | 24% Uncommon | 45 pts |
| Bronze | Eye Witness | Witness a predator killing an enemy. | 24.2% Uncommon | 44 pts |
| Bronze | Spit Roast | Perform a double assassination using a musket. | 24.5% Uncommon | 44 pts |
| Silver | Fin | Complete each of the epilogue missions unlocked after the credits roll. | 24.8% Uncommon | 66 pts |
| Bronze | Tumblehome | Upgrade the Aquila. | 26.7% Uncommon | 42 pts |
| Silver | No Good Deed Goes Unpunished | Open the Temple Door and learn Desmond's fate. | 30.4% Uncommon | 58 pts |
| Gold | The Sum of Truth | Complete Sequence 12. | 37% Uncommon | 69 pts |
| Bronze | Circus Act | Kill 15 guards with a single cannon shot. | 37.4% Uncommon | 34 pts |
| Bronze | Difficult End | Complete Sequence 11. | 39.3% Uncommon | 33 pts |
| Bronze | Whit's fur ye'll no go by ye! | Block a firing line 5 times by using a human shield. | 39.3% Uncommon | 33 pts |
| Silver | The End is Nigh | Complete Present - Abstergo. | 41.2% Common | 48 pts |
| Bronze | Grim Expectations | Complete Sequence 10. | 41.4% Common | 32 pts |
| Silver | Two if by Sea | Complete Sequence 9. | 45.4% Common | 46 pts |
| Bronze | Daddy Dearest | Complete Present - Stadium. | 48.9% Common | 29 pts |
| Bronze | Caged Wolf | Complete Sequence 8. | 49.3% Common | 29 pts |
| Bronze | House Party | Recruit any of the Artisans and see them settled on the Homestead. | 51.2% Common | 28 pts |
| Silver | The Whites of Their Eyes | Complete Sequence 7. | 51.3% Common | 42 pts |
| Silver | Tea is for Englishmen | Complete Sequence 6. | 54.9% Common | 41 pts |
| Bronze | Criss Cross | Complete Present - Skyscraper. | 60.1% Common | 26 pts |
| Bronze | The Day the Templars Cried | Complete Sequence 5. | 60.4% Common | 26 pts |
| Bronze | By Invitation Only | Be invited to join a Club. | 63.5% Common | 25 pts |
| Bronze | Heroes are Born | Complete Sequence 4. | 63.8% Common | 25 pts |
| Bronze | How D'ya Like Them Apples | Complete Sequence 3. | 65.4% Common | 24 pts |
| Bronze | Mystery Guest | Complete Sequence 1 & 2. | 72.1% Common | 23 pts |
| Bronze | Rude Awakening | Re-Enter the Animus. | 91.6% Common | 20 pts |