| Platinum | Big Game Hunter | Obtain all other Midnight Suns Trophies | 1.2% Ultra Rare | 1,076 pts |
| Bronze | T.H.R.E.A.T. Eliminated | Survive 3 turns in the THREAT Room with every hero. | 1.8% Ultra Rare | 211 pts |
| Bronze | A Growing Darkness | Reach maximum Dark Balance. | 2.4% Ultra Rare | 177 pts |
| Bronze | Wisdom of the Woods | Collect 10 of every Reagent. | 3.1% Ultra Rare | 152 pts |
| Bronze | Cape of Many Colors | Apply a Suit palette to every Hero in a single campaign. | 3.6% Ultra Rare | 139 pts |
| Bronze | Fully Armed | Acquire every Hunter ability. | 3.9% Ultra Rare | 133 pts |
| Bronze | You Have the Lead | Complete a general mission led by every hero. | 5.3% Very Rare | 110 pts |
| Silver | Fully Operational | Build every Abbey upgrade in a single campaign. | 5.6% Very Rare | 160 pts |
| Bronze | The Best Girl | Pet Charlie 15 days in a row. | 5.8% Very Rare | 104 pts |
| Silver | Hunter the Explorer | Find every Haven on the Abbey Grounds in a single campaign. | 6.8% Very Rare | 142 pts |
| Bronze | Spread the Pain | Complete a Daily Sparring session with every hero. | 6.9% Very Rare | 94 pts |
| Silver | Extracurricular Activities | Attend all Abbey Club meetings in a single campaign. | 7.7% Very Rare | 132 pts |
| Bronze | Needful Things | Use 25 combat items. | 7.8% Very Rare | 87 pts |
| Bronze | A Shining Light | Reach maximum Light Balance. | 8.1% Very Rare | 86 pts |
| Bronze | Some Minor Adjustments | Apply mods to 10 different hero abilities. | 8.4% Very Rare | 84 pts |
| Bronze | KKRRAKATHOOM | Spend 10 Heroism with a single ability. | 8.5% Very Rare | 83 pts |
| Bronze | Unrequited Love | Pet Ebony on 4 different days. | 8.7% Very Rare | 82 pts |
| Bronze | And Look Good Doing It | Spend 1500 Gloss on cosmetic options for the Hunter. | 8.8% Very Rare | 81 pts |
| Gold | Family is Forever | Complete the Transia story missions. | 9.7% Very Rare | 153 pts |
| Silver | A Mother's Gift | Solve the mystery of Lilith's Garden. | 10% Rare | 113 pts |
| Bronze | Set's Favor | Acquire the "Break" Word of Power. | 10.1% Rare | 75 pts |
| Bronze | Not a Scratch | Complete a general mission where no hero takes Health damage. | 10.3% Rare | 74 pts |
| Bronze | Collateral Damage | KO 4 enemies with a single environmental. | 10.4% Rare | 74 pts |
| Silver | Big Guns | Use 3 different Legendary hero abilities in a single mission. | 10.5% Rare | 110 pts |
| Bronze | Challenge Accepted | Complete 10 Mission Challenges. | 11.1% Rare | 71 pts |
| Bronze | Hyppus' Aid | Acquire the "Purify" Word of Power. | 11.2% Rare | 70 pts |
| Bronze | A Coven Restored | Solve the mystery of Hiram Shaw's church. | 11.8% Rare | 68 pts |
| Gold | Big Mad | Complete the Southwest story missions. | 12.4% Rare | 132 pts |
| Bronze | Did We Just Become Best Friends? | Reach the maximum Friendship Level with any hero. | 12.7% Rare | 65 pts |
| Bronze | Kitchen Sink | Use 5 environmentals in a single turn. | 12.7% Rare | 65 pts |
| Bronze | The Keymaster | Open 25 Arcane Chests. | 12.8% Rare | 65 pts |
| Bronze | Back in Time for Lunch | Complete a general mission in 2 turns or less. | 13.7% Rare | 62 pts |
| Bronze | Atum's Call | Acquire the "Reveal" Word of Power. | 14% Rare | 62 pts |
| Bronze | Friendship is Magic | Reach the maximum Team Friendship Level in the Abbey. | 14.2% Rare | 61 pts |
| Bronze | Dream Team | KO a villain with a Hero Combo. | 14.3% Rare | 61 pts |
| Bronze | We Have Ways | Interrogate 5 enemies. | 14.8% Rare | 60 pts |
| Bronze | Wilhelm Scream | Knockback 2 enemies into Drops in a single turn. | 15% Rare | 59 pts |
| Bronze | Fire Burn and Cauldron Bubble | Use Agatha's Cauldron to complete a Recipe. | 15.1% Rare | 59 pts |
| Bronze | Make a House a Home | Purchase 10 different upgrades for the Hunter's Quarters. | 15.2% Rare | 59 pts |
| Bronze | You Absolute Legend | Complete a Midnight Sun Challenge in the Forge. | 16.1% Rare | 57 pts |
| Gold | A Light Extinguished | Complete the New York story missions. | 16.3% Rare | 112 pts |
| Bronze | Elemental, My Dear Agatha | Solve the mystery of Agatha's Altar. | 16.8% Rare | 55 pts |
| Bronze | Quantity is Quality | Use 8 hero abilities in a single turn. | 16.9% Rare | 55 pts |
| Bronze | Trading Up | Redraw 75 cards. | 17.5% Rare | 54 pts |
| Bronze | With a Box of Scraps | Craft a hero ability card in the Forge. | 17.6% Rare | 54 pts |
| Bronze | Pinball Wizard | KO multiple enemies with a single Knockback 25 times. | 17.8% Rare | 53 pts |
| Bronze | Speed Kills | KO a villain with a Quick ability. | 20.5% Uncommon | 49 pts |
| Bronze | Might Need Pockets | Craft a combat item at the Item Bench. | 23.5% Uncommon | 45 pts |
| Bronze | Are You On Superlink? | Gain a Friendship Level with any hero. | 23.8% Uncommon | 45 pts |
| Bronze | Oshtur's Gift | Acquire the "Open" Word of Power. | 30.6% Uncommon | 39 pts |
| Bronze | Lilith Returns | Complete the tutorial. | 52.8% Common | 28 pts |