| Platinum | The Bright Lord | Middle-earth has been saved. For now... | 1.9% Ultra Rare | 272 pts |
| Bronze | Trolling | Kill a Captain while riding an Olog. | 3.2% Ultra Rare | 50 pts |
| Bronze | Wild Things | Kill a drake while riding a graug. | 3.9% Ultra Rare | 44 pts |
| Bronze | If You Can't Beat Them | Recruit an Orc after he's killed you three or more times. | 5.1% Very Rare | 38 pts |
| Bronze | Such Great Heights | Reach the rank of Captain in Online Conquest. | 5.2% Very Rare | 37 pts |
| Silver | No Orc Lives Forever | Win all Fight Pit missions. | 7.2% Very Rare | 46 pts |
| Bronze | Blood on Blood | Make a Captain kill his bloodbrother. | 7.6% Very Rare | 30 pts |
| Bronze | Death is not the End | Resurrect a Follower Captain. | 8.1% Very Rare | 29 pts |
| Bronze | Life of the Party | Send a Destroyer on a Vendetta Mission. | 8.6% Very Rare | 28 pts |
| Bronze | Rough Rider | Ride every type of beast and rare beast. | 8.9% Very Rare | 27 pts |
| Bronze | Bad Boss | Strike a Follower until he's had enough. | 10.1% Rare | 25 pts |
| Bronze | Overkill | Send a Follower to kill another Follower in a pit fight. | 11.1% Rare | 24 pts |
| Silver | Peace in Death | Complete the Shadow Wars. | 11.9% Rare | 34 pts |
| Bronze | Vertical Mobility | Help a grunt become an Overlord. | 12.1% Rare | 22 pts |
| Bronze | Everything is Permitted | Shame an Assassin until he becomes deranged. | 12.4% Rare | 22 pts |
| Bronze | Finished Tales | Recover all Gondorian artifacts. | 12.7% Rare | 22 pts |
| Bronze | It Came From Within | Start a Conquest with all Warchiefs as spies. | 13.6% Rare | 21 pts |
| Bronze | The Web Revealed | Uncover the final Shelob memory and reveal the Web of Fate. | 15.4% Rare | 19 pts |
| Bronze | Second Age Warrior | Complete all Shadow of the Past missions in one region. | 15.8% Rare | 19 pts |
| Bronze | Master Forger | Forge a top tier Gem. | 17.2% Rare | 18 pts |
| Bronze | No Orc Left Behind | Rescue a Follower who's been captured. | 20.2% Uncommon | 16 pts |
| Silver | Banish the Darkness | Complete all Eltariel quests. | 22.2% Uncommon | 23 pts |
| Silver | Undeath Defeats Undeath | Complete all Carnán quests. | 22.6% Uncommon | 23 pts |
| Bronze | Forged by War | Unlock all player skills. | 23.3% Uncommon | 15 pts |
| Gold | Stalemate is Victory | Defeat the Witch-king and reclaim Minas Morgul. | 25.6% Uncommon | 29 pts |
| Bronze | Purge | Purify all the Haedir. | 26% Uncommon | 14 pts |
| Bronze | The Stuff of Legend | Equip a full Legendary Gear set as Talion. | 26% Uncommon | 14 pts |
| Silver | Fall and Rise | Complete all Brûz quests. | 26.2% Uncommon | 21 pts |
| Bronze | The Operative | Turn all of a Warchief's bodyguards (minimum 2) into spies, then confront him. | 27.4% Uncommon | 14 pts |
| Bronze | Follower Perks | Use a Training Order to give a Follower a gang. | 27.9% Uncommon | 14 pts |
| Silver | Brought to Heel | Defeat Helm Hammerhand. | 29.1% Uncommon | 20 pts |
| Bronze | Power Couple | Send a Follower to support another Follower in a Nemesis Mission. | 31.2% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | Feed the Beasts | Attract every kind of beast using bait. | 31.5% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Silver | For Gondor | Complete all Gondor quests. | 31.7% Uncommon | 19 pts |
| Bronze | Bound by Blood | Complete an Online Vendetta. | 31.8% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | Promise Keeper | Issue a Death Threat, and then successfully kill the target. | 31.9% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Silver | Banished | Defeat Suladân. | 32% Uncommon | 19 pts |
| Silver | Lord of Horror | Defeat the Balrog. | 32% Uncommon | 19 pts |
| Bronze | Headhunter | Recruit a Follower of every Advanced Class. | 36.7% Uncommon | 12 pts |
| Bronze | Speak Friend and Enter | Open one of the Ithildin Doors. | 37.7% Uncommon | 11 pts |
| Bronze | Best Defense | Equip 3 Siege Upgrades on an Assault Team. | 37.9% Uncommon | 11 pts |
| Bronze | Nemesis | Encounter the same Orc 3 times in nemesis missions without killing him. | 39.4% Uncommon | 11 pts |
| Silver | First Steps | Conquer the Fortress of Núrnen. | 43.3% Common | 16 pts |
| Bronze | I Like to Watch | Watch a Follower murder another Captain without helping him. | 43.9% Common | 10 pts |
| Silver | What Once Was Lost | Complete Act I. | 47.6% Common | 15 pts |
| Bronze | Vandal | Destroy a Monument. | 49.4% Common | 10 pts |
| Bronze | Forger | Forge a higher-quality Gem by combining three Gems of the same quality. | 50.1% Common | 10 pts |
| Bronze | Dismantled | Disable an Outpost. | 50.3% Common | 10 pts |
| Bronze | Rule of Three | Unlock 3 Gem slots. | 50.9% Common | 9 pts |
| Bronze | Hostile Takeover | Defeat a Warchief. | 51.8% Common | 9 pts |
| Bronze | Fit for War | Complete a challenge to upgrade a piece of gear. | 52.5% Common | 9 pts |
| Bronze | Avenged | Complete a Vendetta Mission. | 59.3% Common | 9 pts |
| Bronze | Better Luck Next Time | Meet an Enemy or a Follower who has cheated death. | 66.4% Common | 8 pts |