| Platinum | Home Run Derby Champ | Earn all other trophies | 2.2% Ultra Rare | 249 pts |
| Gold | Calling the Shots | Hit 100 multiplier targets | 3.3% Ultra Rare | 98 pts |
| Gold | Bat-Man | Earn 500,000 points | 5.2% Very Rare | 74 pts |
| Silver | Swinging for the Fences | Hit 25 multiplier targets | 16.1% Rare | 28 pts |
| Silver | Rock and Roller | Hit 25 home runs at Progressive Field, home of the 2019 All-Star Game | 17.4% Rare | 27 pts |
| Silver | South Beach Swatter | Hit 25 home runs at loanDepot Park, home of the 2017 All-Star Game | 18% Rare | 26 pts |
| Gold | Barrel Rider | Hit 20 home runs with a launch angle between 26-30 degrees and an exit velocity of 98+ mph | 22.4% Uncommon | 31 pts |
| Gold | All-Star Champ | Hit 6 home runs in a row | 25.7% Uncommon | 29 pts |
| Silver | Commander-In-Chief | Hit 25 home runs at Nationals Park, home of the 2018 All-Star Game | 26.5% Uncommon | 21 pts |
| Gold | Centennial Slugger | Hit 100 home runs
| 29.5% Uncommon | 26 pts |
| Silver | 50K? No Problem | Earn 50,000 points | 45.6% Common | 15 pts |
| Bronze | Left-Hander | Play a round as a left-handed batter | 46.9% Common | 10 pts |
| Bronze | I Got 5 on It | Hit 5 multiplier targets | 49.2% Common | 10 pts |
| Silver | The Sweet Spot | Hit 10 home runs with a launch angle between 25-35 degrees | 58.2% Common | 13 pts |
| Gold | That Still Only Counts as One! | Hit a home run farther than 520 feet | 60.4% Common | 17 pts |
| Silver | Back-to-Back-to-Back | Hit 3 home runs in a row | 67.5% Common | 12 pts |
| Silver | Going, Going, Gone | Hit a home run farther than 500 feet | 70.1% Common | 12 pts |
| Bronze | Right-Hander | Play a round as a right-handed batter | 82.6% Common | 7 pts |
| Gold | It's Outta Here! | Hit a ball with an exit velocity of 125+ mph | 83.7% Common | 14 pts |
| Bronze | Welcome to the Big Leagues! | Hit your first home run | 85.6% Common | 7 pts |
| Silver | He's on Fire! | Hit a ball with an exit velocity of 105+ mph | 86.5% Common | 10 pts |