| Platinum | Season 2 Complete | Unlock all The Darkside Detective Season: A Fumble in the Dark trophies | 12.4% Rare | 88 pts |
| Gold | Slender Fan | Listen to all Inhuman League tracks. | 13.2% Rare | 43 pts |
| Silver | Matchmaker | Help find true love. | 14.9% Rare | 30 pts |
| Silver | Well Well Well... | Discover the well's secret... | 15.3% Rare | 29 pts |
| Gold | Wisdom Seeker | Ask the masters for their worldy wisdom. | 15.5% Rare | 39 pts |
| Gold | Light Reader | Find the pop-up image in each case. | 15.6% Rare | 38 pts |
| Silver | Teach An Old Dog New Tricks | Teach an old dog a trick - was that not clear? | 15.6% Rare | 29 pts |
| Gold | Resource Hogs | Drain Nanny's supply of sandwiches and tea. | 16.3% Rare | 37 pts |
| Gold | Manhandler | Poke McQueen 50 times. | 17.6% Rare | 36 pts |
| Silver | Playing With Fire | Ruin the demon's downtime. | 18.4% Rare | 26 pts |
| Gold | Unwanted Dinner Guest | Interupt a scary, yet romantic, dinner. | 25.5% Uncommon | 29 pts |
| Silver | Heavy Petting | Pet all the animals in the game. | 25.8% Uncommon | 21 pts |
| Gold | Time Cop | Find all the flashbacks of Dooley's Darkside adventures. | 26.6% Uncommon | 28 pts |
| Silver | The Boys Are Back | Watch the credits to fully reinstate The Darkside Division. | 27.2% Uncommon | 21 pts |
| Bronze | High School Graduates | Complete Case 6: Class of the Titans | 27.6% Uncommon | 14 pts |
| Bronze | Too Cool For School | Is Dooley a cool cat? | 28.1% Uncommon | 14 pts |
| Bronze | Bum Ride | Break the clown car. | 28.9% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | Tag Team Champs | Complete Case 5: Royal Fumble | 29.5% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Silver | Busy Body | Examine all of Nanny Dooley's stash. | 30.5% Uncommon | 19 pts |
| Bronze | Sircus Survivor | Complete Case 4: Funfair Dismissal | 31.2% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Bronze | The Luck Of The Irish | Complete Case 3: Druid's Delight | 33.4% Uncommon | 12 pts |
| Bronze | Two Days To Retirement | Complete Case 2: Twilight Years | 35.9% Uncommon | 12 pts |
| Bronze | You Answered The Call | Complete Case 1: Missing, Presumed Darkside | 40.5% Common | 11 pts |
| Silver | An Eye For Detail | Spot what Gary was up to on the switchboard roof. | 50% Common | 14 pts |