| Platinum | The Last Flame | Unlock all other trophies and complete the story of the campfire. | 86.2% Common | −28 pts |
| Gold | Shadows Beside the Fire | Confront the unknown visitor and face the fear beyond the flames. | 86.8% Common | −14 pts |
| Gold | Oasis of the Heart | Find peace in the story’s end — the oasis was never a place, but a feeling. | 86.9% Common | −14 pts |
| Gold | Loyal Companion | Stay by your dog’s side through every chapter of the night. | 88.7% Common | −14 pts |
| Gold | Ashes of the Night | Discover that not all stories end when the storm passes. | 89.2% Common | −14 pts |
| Gold | Voice of the Fire | Listen to the campfire’s whisper and remember its warmth. | 90.3% Common | −13 pts |
| Gold | The First Word | Begin your journey into the frozen woods. | 91% Common | −13 pts |
| Gold | The Morning After | Wake to a silent forest under a pale new sun. | 91.2% Common | −13 pts |
| Gold | Shelter and Silence | Find refuge in your tent as the storm howls outside. | 92.2% Common | −13 pts |
| Gold | Between Fear and Flame | Keep the fire alive when darkness closes in. | 93.7% Common | −13 pts |
| Gold | Eyes in the Trees | Spot the shadowy figure beyond the firelight. | 94.7% Common | −13 pts |
| Silver | Footsteps in the White | Discover the strange footprints buried deep in the snow. | 95.3% Common | −10 pts |
| Silver | Whispers in the Dark | Uncover the truth behind the faint voices within the storm. | 95.3% Common | −10 pts |
| Silver | Echoes of the Wind | Hear the forest whisper for the first time in the dead of night. | 97.2% Common | −10 pts |
| Silver | The Storm Approaches | Survive the first icy winds and strengthen your campfire. | 97.6% Common | −10 pts |
| Bronze | Gathering Light | Help your loyal dog bring back wood to keep the fire alive. | 98% Common | −6 pts |
| Bronze | A Flicker in the Snow | Witness the first spark of the campfire as the snow begins to fall. | 99% Common | −6 pts |