| Platinum | Exsanguination | Unlock all Trophies | 3% Ultra Rare | 207 pts |
| Gold | Chosen-in-Regress | Defeat the 3 Beasts of Beauty and the Beast (E6M8) in under 3 minutes on Well Done difficulty or above | 3.3% Ultra Rare | 98 pts |
| Gold | I'm Not Staying in This Freaking House Another Second | Complete The Haunting (E2M5) in under 40 seconds | 4.6% Ultra Rare | 80 pts |
| Gold | Watch out for Pedestrians | Complete Ghost Town (E3M1) without any Innocents getting killed | 5% Very Rare | 76 pts |
| Silver | So Forgotten That They're Still Full of Cultists | Find the secret level in Post Mortem | 6% Very Rare | 51 pts |
| Silver | The Legend... | Find the secret level in Cryptic Passage | 7.8% Very Rare | 44 pts |
| Gold | Better Left Buried | Find the secret level in Farewell to Arms | 8% Very Rare | 57 pts |
| Gold | Shopping Spree! | Find the secret level in Dead Reckoning | 8.9% Very Rare | 54 pts |
| Silver | The Nightmare Ends | Complete Cryptic Passage | 11.1% Rare | 35 pts |
| Gold | Should Have Gone to the Beach | Find the secret level in Even Death May Die | 11.7% Rare | 46 pts |
| Silver | Priest, Beast, Deceased | Complete Post Mortem | 14.5% Rare | 30 pts |
| Silver | Thine Is the Kingdom | Complete Dead Reckoning | 18.4% Rare | 26 pts |
| Silver | Oh My God... You're Rabid!? | Exploit the Hellhound's greatest weakness | 18.6% Rare | 26 pts |
| Gold | Digestive Irritant | Find the secret level in The Way of All Flesh | 18.9% Rare | 34 pts |
| Silver | Rest in Pieces | Complete Farewell to Arms | 20.3% Uncommon | 25 pts |
| Bronze | Beneath the Floorboards | Find a super secret | 23.6% Uncommon | 15 pts |
| Silver | Forgive Me, Old Friend | Complete Even Death May Die | 24.5% Uncommon | 22 pts |
| Bronze | I Die... Again | Kill yourself 10 times in single-player | 30.1% Uncommon | 13 pts |
| Silver | Sleep, Ophelia | Complete The Way of All Flesh | 36.7% Uncommon | 17 pts |
| Bronze | Swallow This | Kill a Choking Hand | 43.8% Common | 10 pts |
| Bronze | Maranax MaranAAAHHHHHH | Kill 100 Cultists | 52.2% Common | 9 pts |