| Platinum | All Work No Play | Complete all of the original trophies. | 0.1% Ultra Rare | 4,777 pts |
| Gold | Conch Climber | Bring the conch shell to top of mountain | 0.1% Ultra Rare | 2,389 pts |
| Gold | Go Sports! | Bring foam hand to Booster Club Arena | 0.1% Ultra Rare | 2,389 pts |
| Gold | Veteran Driver | Complete 100 different deliveries | 0.1% Ultra Rare | 2,389 pts |
| Silver | Pirate's Booty | Put treasure chest on sloop | 0.1% Ultra Rare | 1,791 pts |
| Gold | Macho Libre | Bring the luchador mask to wrestling ring | 0.2% Ultra Rare | 1,576 pts |
| Gold | Welcome Home | Bring grill to Dad Statue in Golden Ruins | 0.2% Ultra Rare | 1,576 pts |
| Gold | Monkey Motel | Bring banana to room 5 at Banana Motel | 0.2% Ultra Rare | 1,576 pts |
| Gold | Sat-o-lite | Return the satellite to GASA | 0.2% Ultra Rare | 1,576 pts |
| Silver | Expert Driver | Complete 50 different deliveries | 0.3% Ultra Rare | 927 pts |
| Bronze | This is getting Dangerous | Unlock the rocket booster | 0.4% Ultra Rare | 520 pts |
| Bronze | Crop Duster | Pass gas in a biplane | 0.6% Ultra Rare | 408 pts |
| Bronze | tinyBuild | Find the tiny island | 1.3% Ultra Rare | 256 pts |
| Bronze | It's a Flying Car! | Unlock the helicopter | 1.4% Ultra Rare | 245 pts |
| Bronze | Yet Another New Car! | Unlock the pickup truck | 1.5% Ultra Rare | 235 pts |
| Bronze | Keister | Visit Keister Island | 2.8% Ultra Rare | 162 pts |
| Bronze | Novice Driver | Complete 10 different deliveries | 2.9% Ultra Rare | 158 pts |
| Bronze | It's for Science | Visit Gasa Research Facility | 3.5% Ultra Rare | 141 pts |
| Bronze | Another New Car! | Unlock the buggy | 3.7% Ultra Rare | 137 pts |
| Gold | Tornad-Oh! | Lose pants in tornado at Happy Clam Resort | 5.9% Very Rare | 207 pts |
| Bronze | A New Car! | Unlock the mule | 8.9% Very Rare | 81 pts |
| Bronze | Vacation Time | Visit Happy Clam Resort | 9.5% Very Rare | 78 pts |
| Silver | Freefall | Remain airborne for 10 seconds | 24.2% Uncommon | 67 pts |
| Bronze | First Day on the Job | Complete first delivery | 32.9% Uncommon | 37 pts |
| Bronze | Wardrobe Makeover | Change your clothes | 68.7% Common | 24 pts |