The Innsmouth Case Trophies: Rarity, Points & Difficulty

The Innsmouth Case has a 23.5% platinum. The full trophy list earns 541 RarityRank points. Not shovelware: every trophy counts at full value.

Also on PS4

Base Game

TypeTrophyDescriptionRarityPoints
PlatinumMaster SleuthUnlock all the Trophies23.5% Uncommon60 pts
GoldCthulhu fhtagn!Played through all endings23.6% Uncommon30 pts
GoldPain in the...Annoyed Dahlia to death23.9% Uncommon30 pts
GoldSeen it AllDiscovered all of Innsmouth23.9% Uncommon30 pts
GoldKarmaWrongdoings have consequences24% Uncommon30 pts
GoldVegan, by the wayMentioned your vegan lifestyle 3 times24% Uncommon30 pts
BronzeSaviorSaved from the stake24.5% Uncommon15 pts
GoldCompassionDahlia spared your life24.8% Uncommon29 pts
SilverAncient SpiceSlept with Priscilla24.9% Uncommon22 pts
BronzeHard TruthsTraumatized Evelyn25.1% Uncommon14 pts
SilverIs this the bathroom?Snooped through the Marsh Family records25.2% Uncommon22 pts
BronzePenny PincherUsed dirty methods to avoid payment25.7% Uncommon14 pts
SilverNot On My WatchOverpowered the gawper26.4% Uncommon21 pts
GoldSurvivorWendy found a safe place27.3% Uncommon28 pts
BronzeBFFsBecame friends with Jonah27.4% Uncommon14 pts
BronzeVideo Games are EvilPlayed a creepy Arcade Game27.8% Uncommon14 pts
SilverHistory LessonDiscovered fragments from Innsmouth’s history28.2% Uncommon20 pts
SilverStrong-WilledDidn’t touch the cube in the lighthouse29% Uncommon20 pts
BronzeBy Any Means NecessarySeduced Ethel29.4% Uncommon13 pts
SilverWall of the WeirdSnooped through an abandoned hotel room29.7% Uncommon20 pts
SilverI Want To Believe – The I FilesFound a couple of weird City Hall records30% Uncommon19 pts
BronzeIt must be a maskSlept with a fish creature32.6% Uncommon12 pts
BronzeOne Night StandSpent a night with Dahlia33.4% Uncommon12 pts
GoldWelcome to the Hotel MassachusettsSurvived a night in the Gilman Hotel36.2% Uncommon23 pts