| Platinum | Platinum Trophy | Acquire all trophies | 1.1% Ultra Rare | 1,133 pts |
| Gold | Ritual of the Nightmare | Complete all levels including the Hidden objectives on Nightmare | 1.8% Ultra Rare | 422 pts |
| Bronze | Love Letters | Find all lore notes in Deadly Lover's Fortress | 1.9% Ultra Rare | 204 pts |
| Bronze | Book of the Dead | Find all lore notes in Sewers of the Dead | 2% Ultra Rare | 198 pts |
| Silver | Sewers of Nightmare | Complete Sewers of the Dead on Nightmare Difficulty | 2.1% Ultra Rare | 288 pts |
| Bronze | Maids of the Fortress | Find all the dolls in Deadly Lover's Fortress | 2.1% Ultra Rare | 192 pts |
| Silver | Deadly Lover's Nightmare | Complete Deadly Lover's Fortress on Nightmare Difficulty | 2.2% Ultra Rare | 280 pts |
| Bronze | Maids of the Dead | Find all the dolls in Sewers of the Dead | 2.2% Ultra Rare | 187 pts |
| Bronze | Rat Race | Complete Sewers of the Dead under 35 minutes | 2.4% Ultra Rare | 177 pts |
| Bronze | Inn and Out | Complete The Ashes of Sker Hotel under 25 minutes | 2.4% Ultra Rare | 177 pts |
| Silver | Nightmare of Sker Hotel | Complete The Ashes of Sker Hotel on Nightmare Difficulty | 2.5% Ultra Rare | 260 pts |
| Silver | Hardcore Sewer Rat | Complete Sewers of the Dead on Hard Difficulty | 2.6% Ultra Rare | 254 pts |
| Bronze | Maids of Sker | Find all the dolls in Sker Hotel | 2.6% Ultra Rare | 169 pts |
| Bronze | One Night Stand | Complete Deadly Lover's Fortress under 35 minutes | 2.7% Ultra Rare | 165 pts |
| Silver | Hard to Love | Complete Deadly Lover's Fortress on Hard Difficulty | 2.9% Ultra Rare | 238 pts |
| Silver | Hotel of Hard Knocks | Complete The Ashes of Sker Hotel on Hard Difficulty | 3.3% Ultra Rare | 220 pts |
| Bronze | Live, Laugh, Love | Complete "Gates of the Damned Part I" without receiving damage | 3.4% Ultra Rare | 144 pts |
| Bronze | Run Forest! Run! | Complete Cursed Lands of Lavernock under 30 minutes | 3.5% Ultra Rare | 141 pts |
| Bronze | Ramblings of a Madman | Find all lore notes in Cursed Lands of Lavernock | 3.5% Ultra Rare | 141 pts |
| Bronze | Dark Side | Survive a Dark Round without receiving damage | 3.6% Ultra Rare | 139 pts |
| Silver | Nightmare in the Lands of Lavernock | Complete Cursed Lands of Lavernock on Nightmare Difficulty | 3.8% Ultra Rare | 202 pts |
| Bronze | Maids of Lavernock | Find all the dolls in Lavernock | 4.3% Ultra Rare | 125 pts |
| Bronze | Radio Silence | Complete the radio tower objective without receiving damage | 4.9% Ultra Rare | 116 pts |
| Bronze | Guest Book | Find all lore notes in The Ashes of Sker Hotel | 5.4% Very Rare | 109 pts |
| Silver | Hard Times at Lavernock | Complete Cursed Lands of Lavernock on Hard Difficulty | 6% Very Rare | 154 pts |
| Silver | What's Dead Should Stay Dead | Complete the hidden objective in Sewers of the Dead | 7.7% Very Rare | 132 pts |
| Silver | Round Robin | Survive Round 50 | 7.7% Very Rare | 132 pts |
| Silver | Secret Lover | Complete the hidden objective in Deadly Lover's Fortress | 8% Very Rare | 129 pts |
| Bronze | Speed Dating | Complete the "Weird Science" objective in under 4 minutes | 8.1% Very Rare | 86 pts |
| Silver | Ashes to Ashes | Complete the hidden objective in The Ashes of Sker Hotel | 8.6% Very Rare | 124 pts |
| Bronze | That’s Rank | Rank a gun to max level | 12.5% Rare | 66 pts |
| Silver | Silence of the Lamb | Complete the hidden objective in Cursed Lands of Lavernock | 13.4% Rare | 95 pts |
| Bronze | Sewer Rat | Visit every location in the Sewers of the Dead | 14.9% Rare | 59 pts |
| Bronze | Fast Food | Escort the Quiet One in under 2 minutes | 15.8% Rare | 57 pts |
| Bronze | Rounded Experience | Survive Round 35 | 16.2% Rare | 56 pts |
| Bronze | Room Service | Visit every location in The Ashes of Sker Hotel | 16.4% Rare | 56 pts |
| Bronze | The Lambyrinth | Escort all Lambs in under 5 minutes | 16.5% Rare | 56 pts |
| Bronze | Dungeon Crawler | Visit every location in the Deadly Lover's Fortress | 16.5% Rare | 56 pts |
| Silver | Stranger Thing | Defeat The Stranger | 18.5% Rare | 78 pts |
| Silver | Deadly Lovers | Defeat Elisabeth and Thomas | 18.6% Rare | 78 pts |
| Silver | Bad Reception | Defeat Isaac | 23% Uncommon | 69 pts |
| Bronze | Perkalicious | Have all the perks activated at once | 33.5% Uncommon | 36 pts |
| Bronze | Lavernock Rambler | Visit every location in the Cursed Lands of Lavernock | 36.6% Uncommon | 35 pts |
| Silver | Last Rites | Defeat Abraham | 47.3% Common | 44 pts |
| Bronze | Lamb-baah-ghini | Escort the Lamb to slaughter in under 2 minutes | 48.9% Common | 29 pts |
| Bronze | Miracle Man | Get a Miracle to Legendary | 63.1% Common | 25 pts |
| Bronze | Short Round | Survive Round 20 | 68.5% Common | 24 pts |