| Platinum | The Penitent Two | Complete all Trophies | 4.1% Ultra Rare | 515 pts |
| Silver | A Sharp Rendezvous | Reach the room of the Sentinel of the Emery in under 30 minutes. | 4.9% Ultra Rare | 173 pts |
| Silver | True Martyrdom | Complete 100% of the game. | 5.5% Very Rare | 162 pts |
| Bronze | This Is Blasphemy | Deal more than 250 damage with a single strike. | 6.4% Very Rare | 98 pts |
| Silver | Flawless Penance | After the first fight, defeat any boss without receiving damage. | 6.8% Very Rare | 142 pts |
| Bronze | Warrior of the Silent Sorrow | Unlock all Weapon Memories. | 8% Very Rare | 86 pts |
| Bronze | Still Among Us | Find all of the hidden symbols. | 11.4% Rare | 70 pts |
| Bronze | Weight of Penance | Find all of the Figures in the base game.. | 11.7% Rare | 69 pts |
| Bronze | Full Devotion | Find all of the Rosary Beads in the base game. | 12.3% Rare | 67 pts |
| Bronze | Second Pilgrimage | Reveal the entire base game's map. | 12.6% Rare | 66 pts |
| Bronze | Twisted is the Path of the Miracle | Hear the echoes of the past. | 12.7% Rare | 65 pts |
| Bronze | Acta, Non Verba | Find all of the Prayers in the base game. | 12.7% Rare | 65 pts |
| Gold | Canvas of Light and Time | Unlock Ending A. | 12.8% Rare | 130 pts |
| Bronze | The Work of a Master | Bring every Remembrance to an artisan and turn them into Figures. | 13.6% Rare | 63 pts |
| Bronze | Storm of Death | Unlock the true power of Sarmiento & Centella. | 13.8% Rare | 62 pts |
| Bronze | Two Old Ones Eating Soup | Reunite Cástula with Trifón. | 14% Rare | 62 pts |
| Bronze | Happy New Year! | Toll a bell 12 times. | 16% Rare | 57 pts |
| Bronze | Blessed Incense | Unlock the true power of Veredicto. | 16.4% Rare | 56 pts |
| Gold | Second Psalm | Unlock Ending B. | 18.1% Rare | 106 pts |
| Bronze | A Leap of Faith | Lift the Curse of the Unforgiven. | 18.3% Rare | 52 pts |
| Bronze | No Cherub Left Behind | Free Próximo’s brothers. | 18.4% Rare | 52 pts |
| Bronze | Empty Handed | Purchase all available items in the shop in the City of the Blessed Name. | 18.5% Rare | 52 pts |
| Silver | A Heart of Gold | Defeat the Devotion Incarnate, the last child of the Miracle. | 19.6% Rare | 75 pts |
| Bronze | Nobody Expects the Spanish Inquisition! | Kill every type of enemy in the base game. | 19.7% Rare | 50 pts |
| Bronze | Hide and Seek | Find all the hidden Cobijadas. | 20.2% Uncommon | 49 pts |
| Silver | The Wait is Over | Defeat Eviterno, Father of the Penitents. | 20.6% Uncommon | 73 pts |
| Bronze | The Veteran One | Kill 300 enemies using Sarmiento & Centella. | 20.7% Uncommon | 49 pts |
| Bronze | Edge of Orison | Unlock the true power of Ruego Al Alba. | 20.8% Uncommon | 49 pts |
| Bronze | House of Grief and Hatred | Complete all the battle challenges. | 22.6% Uncommon | 46 pts |
| Bronze | Acquired Taste | Unlock all Bile Flasks. | 24% Uncommon | 45 pts |
| Bronze | Soledad | Unlock all of the Rosary Bead slots. | 24.3% Uncommon | 44 pts |
| Bronze | The Finest Craftmanship | Unlock all slots in the Altarpiece of Favours. | 24.9% Uncommon | 44 pts |
| Bronze | The Merciless One | Execute 50 different enemies. | 26.5% Uncommon | 42 pts |
| Silver | Fermosa Fembra | Defeat Svsona, Fermosa Fembra. | 27% Uncommon | 62 pts |
| Silver | Forged in Fire | Defeat Sínodo, Hymn of a Thousand Voices. | 28.3% Uncommon | 61 pts |
| Bronze | Ultima Ratio | Unlock all Abilities. | 28.8% Uncommon | 40 pts |
| Silver | The Sea dies on the Shore | Defeat Odón of the Confraternity of Salt. | 29.1% Uncommon | 60 pts |
| Silver | The Last Ascension | Defeat Benedicta of the Confraternity of Endless Orison. | 30.4% Uncommon | 58 pts |
| Bronze | The Punished One | Kill 300 enemies using Ruego Al Alba. | 30.5% Uncommon | 39 pts |
| Silver | The Sharpest Tool in the Shed | Defeat the Sentinel of the Emery. | 33.6% Uncommon | 55 pts |
| Bronze | The Anointed One | Kill 300 enemies using Veredicto. | 33.6% Uncommon | 36 pts |
| Silver | Blood and Iron | Defeat Lesmes of the Confraternity of Incorruptible Flesh. | 35.3% Uncommon | 53 pts |
| Silver | Blood and Gold | Defeat Orospina of the Confraternity of Embroiderers. | 36.5% Uncommon | 52 pts |
| Silver | Blood and Dust | Defeat the Great Preceptor Radamés. | 40.7% Common | 49 pts |
| Bronze | Welcome Back! | Fall into spikes and survive. | 55.3% Common | 27 pts |
| Silver | A Thousand Years Later | Defeat the Faceless One, Chisel of Oblivion. | 84.6% Common | 31 pts |