| Platinum | Borderland Defender Round Two | Unlocked all Borderlands 2 trophies | 1.6% Ultra Rare | 905 pts |
| Gold | Challenge Accepted | Completed level 1 of all non-level-specific challenges with a single character | 1.9% Ultra Rare | 408 pts |
| Silver | Did It All | Completed all side missions | 3.1% Ultra Rare | 228 pts |
| Silver | World Traveler | Discovered all named locations | 3.3% Ultra Rare | 220 pts |
| Bronze | So Much Blood! | Gunzerked continuously for 90 seconds | 3.7% Ultra Rare | 137 pts |
| Bronze | Blight Explorer | Discovered all named locations in Eridium Blight, Arid Nexus, and Sawtooth Cauldron | 4.5% Ultra Rare | 122 pts |
| Bronze | Arctic Explorer | Discovered all named locations in Three Horns, Tundra Express, and Frostburn Canyon | 5.2% Very Rare | 112 pts |
| Bronze | Unseen Predator | Remained in Zero's Deception mode for ten seconds straight | 5.9% Very Rare | 103 pts |
| Bronze | Highlands Explorer | Discovered all named locations in The Highlands, Thousand Cuts, and Wildlife Exploitation Preserve | 8.5% Very Rare | 83 pts |
| Bronze | Decked Out | Had Purple-rated gear or better equipped in every slot | 9.2% Very Rare | 79 pts |
| Bronze | Definitely An Italian Plumber | Killed Donkey Mong | 9.8% Very Rare | 76 pts |
| Bronze | What does it mean? | I can't even capture it on my camera | 10.2% Rare | 74 pts |
| Silver | Thresher Thrashed | Defeated Terramorphous the Invincible | 10.5% Rare | 110 pts |
| Bronze | Goliath, Meet David | Allowed a Goliath to level up four times before killing him | 12.2% Rare | 67 pts |
| Silver | Capped Out...For Now | Reached level 50 | 13.2% Rare | 96 pts |
| Bronze | Phased and Confused | Phaselocked 100 enemies | 13.4% Rare | 63 pts |
| Bronze | Went Five Rounds | Completed Round 5 of any Circle of Slaughter | 15.4% Rare | 58 pts |
| Bronze | Feels Like The First Time | Opened the chest at the bus stop in Fyrestone | 17.5% Rare | 54 pts |
| Bronze | High-Flying Hurler | Killed a flying enemy with a thrown Tediore weapon | 17.9% Rare | 53 pts |
| Bronze | Tribute To A Vault Hunter | Got an item from Michael Mamaril | 17.9% Rare | 53 pts |
| Bronze | Sabre Rattler | Killed 100 enemies with the Sabre turret | 19.3% Rare | 51 pts |
| Bronze | Urban Explorer | Discovered all named locations in Sanctuary, Opportunity, and Lynchwood | 21.2% Uncommon | 48 pts |
| Bronze | Sugar Daddy | Tipped Moxxi $10,000 | 22.7% Uncommon | 46 pts |
| Bronze | Up High, Down Low | Gave Claptrap a high five | 24.1% Uncommon | 44 pts |
| Bronze | Cute Loot | Killed a Chubby | 24.8% Uncommon | 44 pts |
| Bronze | Friendship Rules | Revived someone from "Fight for Your Life!" that is on your friends list | 25.2% Uncommon | 43 pts |
| Gold | Cool Story, Bro | Defeated Jack | 25.9% Uncommon | 85 pts |
| Silver | Knowing Is Half The Battle | Completed the mission "Data Mining" | 26.9% Uncommon | 62 pts |
| Silver | Bombs Away | Completed the mission "Toil And Trouble" | 28% Uncommon | 61 pts |
| Bronze | Well That Was Easy | Completed the mission "Shoot This Guy in the Face" | 29.4% Uncommon | 39 pts |
| Silver | An Angel's Wish | Completed the mission "Where Angels Fear To Tread" | 30.5% Uncommon | 58 pts |
| Silver | Identity Theft | Completed the mission "The Man Who Would Be Jack" | 32.3% Uncommon | 56 pts |
| Silver | Always Improving | Reached level 25 | 32.7% Uncommon | 56 pts |
| Bronze | Got The Band Back Together | Completed the mission "The Once and Future Slab" | 33.9% Uncommon | 36 pts |
| Bronze | Farewell, Old Girl | Completed the mission "Wildlife Preservation" | 35.1% Uncommon | 35 pts |
| Bronze | Can See My House From Here | Completed the mission "Bright Lights, Flying City" | 39.6% Uncommon | 33 pts |
| Bronze | Bounty Hunter | Completed 20 side missions | 39.7% Uncommon | 33 pts |
| Bronze | Sky's The Limit | Completed the mission "Rising Action" | 41.3% Common | 32 pts |
| Bronze | Wilhelm Screamed | Completed the mission "A Train To Catch" | 41.8% Common | 32 pts |
| Bronze | Build Buster | Killed a Constructor without it ever building another bot | 42.1% Common | 32 pts |
| Bronze | How Do I Look? | Unlocked 10 customization items | 42.9% Common | 31 pts |
| Bronze | Better Than Money | Purchased 5 items from the black market | 43.8% Common | 31 pts |
| Bronze | Token Gesture | Redeemed 25 tokens | 44.8% Common | 31 pts |
| Bronze | No Man Left Behind | Completed the mission "A Dam Fine Rescue" | 45.8% Common | 30 pts |
| Bronze | An Old Flame | Completed the mission "Hunting The Firehawk" | 52% Common | 28 pts |
| Bronze | Better Than You Were | Reached level 10 | 56.1% Common | 27 pts |
| Bronze | New In Town | Completed the mission "Plan B" | 56.6% Common | 27 pts |
| Bronze | A Road Less Traveled | Completed the mission "The Road To Sanctuary" | 58.2% Common | 26 pts |
| Bronze | Dragon Slayer | Completed the mission "Best Minion Ever" | 63.1% Common | 25 pts |
| Bronze | Not Quite Dead | Reached level 5 | 72.8% Common | 23 pts |
| Bronze | First One's Free | Completed the mission "My First Gun" | 89.4% Common | 20 pts |