| Platinum | Guacamelee! Platinum trophy | Luchador #1! | 2.9% Ultra Rare | 633 pts |
| Gold | That was Hard Mode? | Defeat the game on Hard mode | 3.3% Ultra Rare | 293 pts |
| Gold | Who put these here??? | Achieve 100% completion in all areas | 3.5% Ultra Rare | 283 pts |
| Gold | World Champion | Earn a Gold Medal in all Infierno challenges | 4.1% Ultra Rare | 257 pts |
| Silver | Lore Master | Complete All Side Quests | 4.6% Ultra Rare | 180 pts |
| Silver | Heavyweight | Earn a Bronze Medal in all Infierno challenges | 4.8% Ultra Rare | 176 pts |
| Gold | El Savior | Access the alternative ending (collect all orbs) | 5.3% Very Rare | 221 pts |
| Bronze | Cock of the Walk | Defeat an enemy using the Pollo Bomb | 6.3% Very Rare | 99 pts |
| Gold | The Devil wears Revenge! | Defeat Calaca with full health in Diablo's Suit | 6.4% Very Rare | 197 pts |
| Bronze | I swat you | Defeat a Chupacabra using only Slam | 6.8% Very Rare | 95 pts |
| Silver | Poncho'd Out | Complete the Combo Chicken quest (Defeat Poncho forever) | 7.7% Very Rare | 132 pts |
| Silver | The Never Ending Combo | Achieve a 200 Hit Combo | 10.3% Rare | 111 pts |
| Silver | I Have The Powerrrrrrrr | Purchase 20 Upgrades from the Shop | 13.9% Rare | 93 pts |
| Gold | Boom-Shack-Calaca | Defeat Calaca | 15.7% Rare | 115 pts |
| Silver | Got to catch them all | Find an orb | 18.1% Rare | 79 pts |
| Bronze | Nooks and Crannies | Find 100% of the hidden items in a single area | 18.4% Rare | 52 pts |
| Bronze | Licking his Wounds | Defeat Jaguar Javier | 19.5% Rare | 50 pts |
| Bronze | No Encore! | Defeat El Trio de la Muerte | 21.1% Uncommon | 48 pts |
| Bronze | "Next-gen!!" | Start a New Game on Save Slot #2 | 23% Uncommon | 46 pts |
| Bronze | Snuffed Out | Defeat Flame Face | 25.2% Uncommon | 43 pts |
| Bronze | Combo Nerd | Achieve a 125 Hit Combo | 25.7% Uncommon | 43 pts |
| Bronze | Last Straw | Break Uay Chivo's fake statue in the Tule Tree. | 28.3% Uncommon | 40 pts |
| Bronze | X'tabay-Bye | Redeem X'tabay | 31.7% Uncommon | 38 pts |
| Bronze | Pollo Power | Become a Chicken | 33.8% Uncommon | 36 pts |
| Silver | That was INTENSE | Kill 20 Enemies in a single INTENSO sequence | 34.4% Uncommon | 54 pts |
| Bronze | Main Event | Defeat a Skeleton-Luchador | 35.4% Uncommon | 35 pts |
| Bronze | Power Within | Complete Uay Chivo's Intenso training | 39.8% Uncommon | 33 pts |
| Bronze | That's one big Gato Frito | Kill the Alebrije | 43.6% Common | 31 pts |
| Bronze | Flawless | Defeat an arena without taking any damage | 52.4% Common | 28 pts |
| Bronze | Do or Do Not | Complete the First Combo Chicken Challenge | 58% Common | 26 pts |
| Bronze | Viva La Resurrección | Become a Luchador | 83.2% Common | 21 pts |